´é¶i¥xÆW¥«³õ¡A¦A¥[¤W¥»°ê·~ªÌªº¥Ó½Ð³]¥ß¡A³y¦¨-쥻«Ê³¬¤w¤[ªº²£¹ØÀI¥«³õµ²ºcÆJÅÜ¡C¥H°ê¤ºªº¹ØÀI¤½¥q¬°¨Ò¡A©ó¥Á°ê¤K¤Q¤C¦~®ÉÁ`·~-pªº¤£¨}¦Ó´Xªñ¯}²£¡F¦p¡G¥Á°ê¤K¤Q¤»¦~¡A§»ºÖ¤H¹Ø¡C¥ç¦³¦h®a¥~°Ó¥H¤Î¥»°êªº·s¶i·~ªÌ±N¤½¥qªÑÅvÂàÅý©Î¬O®Ú¥»ºM¥X¥xÆW¥«³õ¡A¥Ø«e§ó¦³³\\¦hªº¹ØÀI¤½¥q©|¿n·¥´M¨D¦X¾Aªº¨ÖÁʹï¶H¡C¦Ó¨s«Y¬O¦óºØ-ì¦]³y¦¨¦p¦¹¤§¥«³õÅÜ-²¡HÀ³»P¹ØÀI¤½¥q¤§¸gÀç®Ä²v¨}æÕ»P§_¨ã¦³°ª«×ªº¬ÛÃö©Ê¡F¦Ó¹ØÀI·~¬É©Ò-±Á{¤§ÃxÁ{¯}²£¡B¦¬ÁʤκM¸êµ¥²{ªp¡A°£¤F¥~µ²ºc¬O§_»P¤§®§®§¬ÛÃö¡A¬O-ȱo±´¨sªºÄ³ÃD¡C
¦³Å²©ó¦¹¡A¥»¬ã¨s±N¥H¹ØÀI¤½¥q¤§¡uªÑÅvµ²ºc¡v¥H¤Î¡u°ª¶¥¥DºÞ¤§Á~¹S¡v¬°¥D-n±´°Q¤§-«ÂI¡CÀ˵ø¨ä¤GªÌ¹ï©ó¹ØÀI¤½¥q¡u¸gÀç®Ä²v¡v©Ò²£¥Í¤§¼vÅT¡C
¥xÆWªº«OÀI¥«³õ¦Û±q¥þ-±¶}©ñ¥H«á¡A°ê»Ú¶¡ª¾¦Wªº«OÀI·~ªÌ¯É¯
ªÌ¼Æ¥Ø´¿¸g¹F¨ì¤T¤Q¤G®a¤§¦h¡F¦ý¬O¤£¹Lµuµu¼Æ¦~´N¦³·~ªÌ¦]«O³æ³]
¦bÀô¹ÒªºÄvª§¿E¯P¥~¡A¤½¥qªº¥D-n¸g²z¤H¤§¸gÀç¯à¤O¥H¤Î¤½¥qªºªÑÅv
1
²Ä¤@¸` ¬ã¨s-I´º»P°Ê¾÷
¥ø·~©Ò¦³Åvªº°ª«×¤À´²¡A¥[¤W²Õ´µ²ºc½ÆÂø¤Æ»P±M·~¤À¤uªº®ï¤Á»Ý-n¡A¨Ï±o©Ò¦³Åv»P¸gÀçÅv¤À´²ªº²{¶H¡A¤w¦¨¬°¥ø·~¸gÀ窺¤@ºØ¥²µMÁͶա]ªL¬³Î]¡A¥Á79¡¡^CBerle and Means¡]1932¡^¦b¡u²{¥NªÑ¥÷¦³--¤½¥q»P¨p¦³°]²£¡v¤ÎJensen and Meckling¡]1976¡^¦b¡u¼t°Ó²z½×¡GºÞ²zªÌªº¦æ¬°¡B¥N²z¦¨¥»©MªÑÅvµ²ºc¡v¤¤«ü¥X©Ò¦³ªÌ»P¸gÀçªÌ¶¡¤§§Q¯q½Ä¬ð©Ò²£¥Íªº¥N²z°ÝÃD¥H¨Ó¡AªÑÅvµ²ºc¡]©Ò¦³ªÌ»P¸gÀçªÌ¶¡ªÑ¥÷ªº¤À°tµ¥¡^»P¤½¥q»ù-È¡B¥ø·~¸gÀçÁZ®Ä¶¡ªºÃö«Y¡A¤@ª½¬O¾ÇªÌ-̦b²z½×¤Î¹ê°È¬ã¨s¤WªºµJÂI¡A¨Ò¦p¡GStulz¡]1988¡^´£¥X¤@-Ó¼Ò¦¡¡AÅçÃÒ¤½¥qªº¥«³õ»ù-ÈÀHµÛ¤º³¡¤H¤hªº«ùªÑ¤ñ¨Ò§e²{¥ý¼W«á´îªº²{¶H¡FMorck¡BShleifer and Vishny¡]1988¡^¤]¤ä«ù¨âªÌ¶¡§e«D½u©ÊÃö«Yªº»¡ªk¡C¥t¥~¡ADemsetz and Lehn¡]1985¡B¡^Morck et al.¡]1988¡^µ¥¤]´£¥XÃÒ¾ÚÃÒ©ú¤½¥qÁZ®Ä»PªÑÅvµ²ºc¶¡ªº¬ÛÃö©Ê¡C
«OÀI·~¤§¸gÀç§Þ³N¤Î¥»½è-~²§©ó¤@¯ë²£·~¡A¨ä¸gÀ窺¥Ø¼Ð¥ç¤£¬Û¦P¡A¤£¶È¥H°l¨D¡uªÑªF°]´I·¥¤j¤Æ¡v¬°¨äÀç¹B¦Ò¶q¡F«OÀI·~ªº¸gÀç§Þ³N°£¤F»Ý°ª«×ªº±M·~ª¾ÃÑ¥~¡A¨ä¸gÀ禨±Ñ§ó¬O¼vÅT¼h-±·¥¼s¡A¹ï©ó-Ó¤H¡BªÀ·|¡B°ê®a¦Ó¨¥¬Ò¦³·¥¤jªº¼vÅT¡F¦Ó«OÀI·~ªº¥i¹B¥Î¸êª÷¨Ó·½°£¤F·~¥DÅv¯q¥~¡Aµ´¤j³¡¤À¬O¨Ó¦Û©ó¦UºØ´£¦sªº³d¥ô·Ç³Æª÷¡A¬°¤@ºØ¨ã°ªºb±ì°]°È¤ñ²v¯S©Ê¤§¦æ·~¡C¦]¬°«OÀI·~¨ã³Æ¤F°ª«×ªº¤½¯q©Ê¡A¦]¦¹¦U°êªººÊ²z³æ¦ì¹ï©ó«OÀI·~¬Ò©ú-q¦³°ª¼Ð·Çªº-n¨D¡A¦Ó§Ú°êªººÊ²z³æ¦ì¹ï©ó¨ä³]¥ß¼Ð·Ç¡B·~°È¸gÀç½d³ò¡B°]°È¸gÀç§Þ³N¥H¤Î±M·~¸g²z¤Hªº¥ô¥Î¸ê®æ¡A¬Ò¥ß¦³ªk¥O¤©¥H³W½d¡C
¦Ó«OÀI·~¬O§_¦p¤@¯ë²£·~¦s¦b¦³¬Û¦Pªº¥N²z°ÝÃD¬O¥»¬ã¨s©ÒÃö¤Áªº¬ã¨s-«ÂI¤§¤@¡C©Ò¿×¡u¥N²z°ÝÃD¡v¬O°ò©ó¦UºØ¡u¥N²zÃö«Y¡v©Ò-l¥Í¤§°ÝÃD¡A¤S¥N²zÃö«Y¥iÂk¯Ç¬°¨âºØ¡A§Y¡uÅv¯q¥N²zÃö«Y¡v»P¡u-t¶Å¥N²zÃö«Y¡v¡F±q«OÀI·~ªº¸ê¥»µ²ºc¥iµo²{¨ä-t¶Å¤ñ²v»·°ª©óÅv¯q¤ñ
2
²v¡A¦Ó¦¹-t¶Å§¹¥þ¬O¨Ó¦Û©ó«O³æ«ù¦³¤H¡]
policyholders¡^©Òú¥æªº«O
¶O¡A¤]¦]¦¹«OÀI·~ªº¥N²z°ÝÃD°£¤F¨Ó¦ÛªÑªF»P¥D-n¸g²z¤H¤§¶¡ªº¥N²zÃö«Y¥~¡A¥t¤@-«-nªº¥N²zÃö«Y¬°¦s¦b©ó«O¤á¡]¬Û·í©ó¶ÅÅv¤H¡^»PªÑªF¤§¶¡¡F¦¹¤GªÌ¤§¶¡ªº®t²§¦b©ó¡A¹ï©ó¤½¥q¤§ªÑªF¦Ó¨¥§Æ±æ¸g²z¤H¯à¥H°l¨D¡uªÑªF°]´I¤§·¥¤j¤Æ¡v¬°-º-nÀç¹B¥Ø¼Ð¡F¦Ó¹ï©ó«O¤á¦Ó¨¥¡A«o¤£§Æ±æ¸gÀ綥¼h¦b§ë¸ê¤W«_¹L«×ªº-·ÀI¡A¦b¥Gªº¬O«OÀI¤½¥q°]°È°·¥þ¨Ã¯à´£¨Ñ¡u¦w¥þµL¸·¡vªº«O»Ù§Y¥i¡F¦¹¤GªÌ¤§¥N²zÃö«Y¬O§_·|¦³¤¬¥¸ªº²{¶H¡H¦Ó¸g²z¤H¦b-±Á{-«¤jªº§ë¸ê¨Mµ¦®É¬O§_·|¦]¦¹¦Ó¦h©ÒÅU§Ò¡A¶i¦Ó¼vÅT¤½¥q¤§¸gÀç®Ä²v¡H
Ãö©óªÑÅvµ²ºc©M¤½¥q¸gÀçÁZ®Ä¤§¶¡ªºÃö«Y¡A¤@ª½¬O³\\¦h¾ÇªÌ²`·P¿³½ìªº°ÝÃD¡A¤£½×°ê¤º¥~§¡¦³³\\¦h¾ÇªÌ§@¹L¬ÛÃö¬ã¨s¡F¦ý¤ÏÆ[«OÀI²£·~«oÂA¤Ö¦³¤åÄm½×¤Î¨ä¶¡¤§¬ÛÃö©Ê¡A¶È¦³³¯¾åªå¡]¥Á89¡^´¿´N¦¹¤@ijÃD¥[¥H±´°Q¡A¦Ó©Ò±o¨ìªº¬ã¨sµ²ªG¬°¹ØÀI·~ªº¥N²z°ÝÃD¸û¬°©úÅã¡A¦Ó²£ÀI¤½¥q¤è-±«h¥¼¦³ÅãµÛªº¥N²z°ÝÃD¦s¦b¡C¥B¹L¥hªº¤@¯ë¾ÇªÌ¬Ò¥H°]°È-±©Î·|-p-±¤§¡u¸gÀçÁZ®Ä¡v(performance)¬°¨ä¿Å¶q¨Ì¾Ú¡A¥»¬ã¨s«h¸Õ¹Ï¥H¸gÀپDz[¸q¤§¡u®Ä²v¡v(efficiency)¤@µü¬°¿Å¶q¤§¼Ðªº¡C
¥Ñ©ó¥~°Ó¦b¥x¤§¤À¤½¥q¨äªÑÅv¸ê®Æ¨ÃµL´¦ÅS¡A¬G¥»¤å±N¥H¥xÆWªº¥»°ê¹ØÀI¤½¥q¬°¬ã¨s¹ï¶H§@¤@²`¤J±´°Q¡A¥H¦U¤½¥q¤§ªÑÅvª¬ªp¨Ó¤ÀªR¡A¬O§_»P¸gÀç®Ä²v¤§¶¡¨ã¦³¬Û·íµ{«×ªºÃöÁp¡F¦¹¥~¡A¥»¬ã¨s°£¤F±´°QªÑÅvµ²ºc¹ï©ó¹ØÀI¤½¥qªº¸gÀç®Ä²v©Ò²£¥Í¤§¼vÅTµ{«×¥~¡A©|°Q½×¹ØÀI¤½¥qªº¡uÁ~¹S¨î«×¡v¬O§_¥ç·|¼vÅT¤½¥q¸gÀ窺®Ä²v¡F´N²z½×¦Ó¨¥¡AºÞ²zªÌªºÁ~¹S¨î«×¦pªG³]-p±o©y¡AÀ³¸Ó¯à°÷¿EÀyºÞ²zªÌ§V¤O¡A¨ÏºÞ²zªÌªºªº¨Mµ¦¦æ¬°§ó¯à²Å¦X¤½¥q¤§¾ãÅé¸gÀç®Ä²v¡C¦]¦¹¡A¤@®M¾A¦X¤½¥q¥»¨-ªººÞ²zªÌÁ~¹Sµ²ºc¡A¥ç¯à¦³®Äªº¸Ñ¨M¥N²z°ÝÃD¡C
3
²Ä¤G¸` ¬ã¨s¥Øªº
¥xÆWªº¹ØÀI¥«³õªñ¦~¨ÓÅÜ°ÊÀW¤´¡A-즳ªº¤T¤Q¤G®a¹ØÀI·~ªÌ¦³ªº¬°¸gÀçÅv©ö¥D¡A¦³ªº²Mºâ-즳·~°È¤§«áºM¥X¥«³õ¡A¥ç¦³¦h®a¹ØÀI¤½¥qªº°ª¶¥¸g²z¤H¤@¾²§°ÊÀW¤´¡F¥H¤WªººØºØ²{¶H°£¤F¾ãÅ饫³õªºÄvª§¼@¯P¤§¥~¡A¦U¹ØÀI·~ªÌªº¸gÀç§Þ³N¤Î¯à¤O¡A¥ç¨¬¥H¼vÅT¸gÀç®Ä²v¤§Àu¦H¡A¦Ó¨s«Y¦óºØ¦]¯À·|¹ï©ó¹ØÀI¤½¥qªº¸gÀç®Ä²v²£¥Í¼vÅT¡A¥H©¹ªº¾ÇªÌ´¿°w¹ï³\\¦hªºÄ³ÃD¨Ó±´¨s¡A¥]¬A¡G¥ø·~§Î¶H¡B¸êª÷¹B¥Î¡B¦æ¾P³q¸ô¡B²£·~µ²ºc¥H¤Î¸gÀ給²¤µ¥¡A¦Ó¥»¤å¸Õ¹Ï±q¡uªÑÅvµ²ºc¡v¥H¤Î¡uÁ~¹S¨î«×¡v¨â¤è-±¨Ó±´°Q¡AÂk¯Ç¤§¬ã¨s°ÝÃD¦p¤U¡G
¤@¡B
°w¹ï¥Á°ê86¦~¦Ü89¦~¶¡¥»°ê¹ØÀI·~ªÌ¤§¬Û¹ï¸gÀç®Ä²v¥[¥H¤ÀªR¡A¨Ã¤ñ¸û¦U¹ØÀI¤½¥q¤§¸³ºÊ¨Æ«ùªÑ¤ñ²v¡AÀ˵ø¦¹¤GªÌ¤§¶¡ªº¬ÛÃöµ{«×¬°¦ó¡C
¤G¡B
±´°Q¥»°ê¹ØÀI·~ªÌªºÁ`¸g²z¤@¾¤§Á~¹Sµ²ºc¡A»P¤½¥qªº¸gÀç®Ä²v¶¡¤§¬ÛÃöÁp©Ê¬°¦ó¡C
¤T¡B
¤½¥q¤º¤§¡uªÑÅv¤À´²µ{«×¡v»P¸gÀç®Ä²v¤§¶¡ªºÃöÁp©Ê¡A¥H©¹ªº¬ã¨s¾ÇªÌ¹ï¦¹Ä³ÃD¨£¸Ñ¯Éª[¡A¥»¤å±N±´°Q¦¹¤@Åܼƹï©ó¹ØÀI·~¸gÀç®Ä²vªº¼vÅT¬°¦ó¡C
4
²Ä¤T¸` ¬ã¨s¤èªk»P¸ê®Æ¨Ó·½
¦b¹L¥h¦³½Ñ¦hªº¤åÄm´¿±´°Q¹ØÀI¤½¥qªº¸gÀçÁZ®ÄijÃD¡A¦ý¬O¿Å¶q¸gÀçÁZ®Äªº«ü¼Ð¦s¦³¦hºØ¡A¦Ó¨Ì¨äµû¦ô·Ç¾Ú¤§¿ï¥Î¥i¥H¤À¬°¨â¤jÃþ¡F§Y³æ¤@·Ç¾ÚªºÁZ®Äµû¦ô¡]univariate effectiveness measures¡^¥H¤Î¦h¤¸
·Ç¾ÚªºÁZ®Äµû¦ô¡]multivariate effectiveness measures¡¡^F©Ò¿×ªº¡u³æ¤@·Ç¾Úªº«ü¼Ð¡v¥]¬A¥Í²£¤O¡B²b§Q¡B¥Ø¼Ð¹F¦¨²v¡B¸ê²£³ø¹S²vµ¥·~°È-±¡B°]°È-±©Î·|-p-±ªº¿Å¶q«ü¼Ð¦Ó¨¥¡A¦ý¬O§^¤H¦b¿ï¨úµû¦ô«ü¼Ð®É¨s«YÀ³¥H¦óªÌ¬°¾Ú¡H±`©ö¾D-P«Dij¤§³B¦b©ó©P©µ©Ê¤£¨¬¡B¥¢¤§¥DÆ[¤Î¾A¤Á©Ê¤£¨¬µ¥°ÝÃD¡]§õ§ÓµØ¡A¥Á71¡C¡^
«OÀI·~ÄÝ©ó¦h-«²£¥X¤Î§ë¤Jªº¦æ·~¡A¦Ó¥Ñ¹L¥hªº¤åÄm¥iª¾¡A¬°¤F¦³®Ä¿Å¶q¦¹µ¥²£·~ªº¸gÀç®Ä²v¥i¥H§Q¥Î--¸ê®Æ¥]µ¸¤ÀªRªk¡]data envelopment analysis ¡ADEA¡¡^F°ê¤º¤w¦³¼Æ¦ì¾ÇªÌ¨Ï¥ÎDEAªk¨Ó¿Å¶q¹ØÀI·~ªº¸gÀç®Ä²v¡G¼B¯Â¤§¡]¥Á83¡¡B§õ§g«Ì¡]¥Á^
83¡¡^B¾G¨q®S¡]¥Á
85¡^§d°êµØ¡]¥Á86¡¡^F¬G¥»¬ã¨s§Y¥HµL¥À¼Æ¤§DEAªk¶i¦æ¹ØÀI·~¤§¸gÀç®Ä²v³¡¤À¬ÛÃö¤§¤ÀªR¡C
¥»¬ã¨s©Ò±Ä¥Îªº¬ã¨s¼Ë¥»¡A¬°°ê¤º¤w¤W¥«»P¤½¶}µo¦æ¤§¹ØÀI¤½¥q¡A¦Ó¨Ï¥Îªº¡uªÑÅvµ²ºc¡v¥H¤Î¡u°ª¶¥¸g²z¤H¹S³Ò¡vµ¥¸ê®Æ¡A¬°¦U¹ØÀI¤½¥q³Ìªñ¤T¦~¡]¥Á86¦~¦Ü88¦~¡^©Òµo§G¤§¡uªÑªF¦~³ø¡v¥H¤Î¡u°]°È³ø§i®Ñ¡¡vA¥Ñ©ó¦¹¨â³¡¤À¸ê®Æ¨ú±o¤£©ö¡A¬°¤½¥q¥ø·~©Ò¤£Ä@»´©ö¹ï¥~´¦ÅS¤§¸ê®Æ¡A©¯¿à³z¹L¡uÃÒ¨éº[´Á³f¥«³õµo®i°òª÷·|¡v¤§±M·~¹Ï®ÑÀ]¦¬¶°¾ã²z¡A¤~±o¥H¶¶§Q¨ú±o¦³Ãöªº¼Æ¾Ú¡F¦Ó¥»¬ã¨s©Òµû¦ô¹ØÀI¤½¥qªº¸gÀç®Ä²v¤§¦U¶µ·~°È¼Æ¾Ú¨Ó·½¡A¥]¬A¤º¥~¶Ô¤H¼Æ¡B·~°ÈºÞ²z¶O¥Î¡B²z½ß¶O¥Î¥H¤Î³d¥ô·Ç³Æª÷µ¥¦U¶µ¡A«h¨Ó¦Û©ó¤H¹Ø«OÀI¦P·~¤½·|©Ò½s¦Lªº¡u¤H¹Ø«OÀI·~°È²Î-p¦~³ø¡¡v]¥Á°ê86¦~¦Ü89¦~¡C¡^
5
²Ä¥|¸`
¬ã¨s--¨î
¥»¬ã¨s¤§¥D-n±´°QªºÄ³ÃD¬°¡uªÑÅvµ²ºc¡B¡¡uÁ~¹S¨îv«×¡v¹ï©ó¥xÆW¹ØÀI¤½¥q¸gÀç®Ä²v¤§¶¡ªº¬ÛÃöµ{«×¡A¦ý¬O¥Ø«e°ê¤ºªº¹ØÀI¤½¥q¦³¥b¼Æ¬O°ê¥~¤½¥q¦b¥xªº¤À¤ä¾÷ºc¡A¦]¦¹¹ï©ó¦¹Ãþ«¬ºAªº·~ªÌ¦Ó¨¥¡AÄݩ󤽥q¤º³¡¤§Àç¹B¸ê®Æ¨Ã¥¼¹ï¥~¤½§G¡A¬G¥»¬ã¨s¶È¯à°w¹ï¥»°ê¤§¹ØÀI·~ªÌ§@¬°¤ÀªR¼Ë¥»¡A¥B¥»°ê¹ØÀI·~ªÌ¤¤¤§«n¤s¤H¹Ø¨äµ´¤j³¡¤ÀªÑÅv¬Ò¥Ñ¡u¬ü°ê°ê»Ú¶°¹Î¡]¡vA.I.G¡^©Ò«ù¦³¡A¦b¹ê½è¤W¬°¤@°ê¥~¦b¥x³]¥ß¤§¤l¤½¥q¡F¤¤¥¡«H°U§½¥»¨-¬°¤@¤½Àç©Ê½è¾÷ºc¡F²Î¤@¤H¹Ø¤Î©¯ºÖ¤H¹Ø¤§¬ÛÃö¦~³ø¤Î°]³ø¸ê®Æ¥ç¬OµL±q¨ú±o¡A¬G¥»¬ã¨sªº¬ã¨s½d³ò¤§--¨î¦b¦©°£¤W-z¤§¤T®a·~ªÌ«á¬°12®a¹ØÀI¤½¥q¡A¦¹¬°²Ä¤@¶µ¬ã¨s--¨î¡C
¦¹¥~¡A¥Ñ©ó¥»¬ã¨s¦b¿Å¶q¹ØÀI¤½¥qªº¸gÀç®Ä²v¤W±Ä¥ÎDEAªk¡A¦b§ë¤J»P²£¥X¶µ¥ØªºÅܼƿï¨ú¤W¡A¦]¬°¡u¹ØÀI·~°È²Î-p¦~³ø¡v¤¤¨ÃµL¸ü¦C¦U®a·~ªÌªº¬ÛÃö¶O¥Î¸ê®Æ¡A¨Ò¦p¤º¥~¶Ô¤H-û¤§¥-§¡Á~¸ê¡B¦þª÷¡B¯²ª÷¡Bºû-׶O¥Îµ¥¡A¦]¦¹¦bÅܼƪº¿ï¨ú¤W¾D¨ü--¨î¡A¥u±o¥H-Y¤z´À¥NÅܼƨú¥N-즳¤§¶µ¥Ø¡A¦ý¥»¬ã¨s°È¨D¹F¨ì¯à¤½¥-¦X²z¥H¤Î¤@-P©Ê¡A¥H-°§C¦ôºâ¤W¤§°¾»~¡C
6
²Ä¤-¸`
¬ã¨s¬[ºc
¬ã¨s-I´º»P°Ê¾÷ ¬É©w¬ã¨s°ÝÃD»P¥Øªº ¬ÛÃö¤åÄm±´°Q «Ø¥ßµû¦ô¼Ò¦¡»PÅܼƽT©w ªÑÅvµ²ºcÅÜ¼Æ ¤§¸ê®Æ»`¶° ¸ê®Æ¥]¸¨¤ÀªRªk ¤§®Ä²vµû¦ô ¹êµý¼Ò«¬¤ÀªR ¬ã¨sµ²½×»P¤ÀªR
7
²Ä¶L³¹ ¤åÄm±´°Q
¤åÄmªº±´°Q¦³§U©ó¬ã¨s¤è¦V¥H¤Î¬ã¨s°ÝÃDªº½T¥ß¡A¥»¬ã¨s©ÒÃö¤Áªº-«ÂI¬°¤½¥qªº¤º³¡±±¨î¹ï©ó¹ØÀI¤½¥q¸gÀç®Ä²v¤§¼vÅTµ{«×¡F¦Ó¬°¤F§ó¶i¤@«×ÁA¸Ñ¹ØÀI¤½¥qªº¥N²z°ÝÃD¡A¥»¤å±N±´°QªÑÅvµ²ºc¤ÎÁ~¹S³]-p¹ï©ó¹ØÀI¤½¥q¸gÀç®Ä²v¤§¼vÅT¡A¤S¥»¬ã¨s±N¥HDEAªk¨Ó¿Å¶q¦U¹ØÀI¤½¥q¤§¶¡ªº¬Û¹ï¸gÀç®Ä²v¡F¦]¦¹¥»³¹±N¹ï©ó¹L¥h¤§¬ÛÃö²z½×¤Î¹êµý¤åÄm§@¤@¦^ÅU»P¾ã²z¡CªÑÅvµ²ºc¥H¤ÎÁ~¹S³]-p¹ï©ó¤½¥q»ù-ȤÎÁZ®Äªí²{¤§µÛ§@¥ç¤£¦b¤Ö¼Æ¡A¦ý¬O¤j¦h¥H¤@¯ë²£·~¬°¥D¡A¨Ã¤£¥]¬Aª÷¿Ä«OÀI·~¡F¦Ó¨Ï¥Î¸gÀپǤ¤ªº¡u®Ä²v«e½tªk¡]¡vFrontier Efficiency Methods¡^¨Ó¤ÀªR¹ØÀI²£·~¤§¬ã¨s¡A¥xÆW¾ÇªÌ©ó¦-´Á¬ÒµL¤H±Ä¥Î¡Aª½¨ì¼B¯Â¤§¡]¥Á83¡^-º«×¨Ï¥Î¤§«á¡Aªñ¦~¨Ó¤w¦³«áÄò¾ÇªÌ¥[¥H¹B¥Î¡A¦ýÆ[½Ñ°ê¤º¥~¾ÇªÌ¤§¦U¶µ¬ã¨s¡A©ó¨Ï¥Î¡u®Ä²v«e½t¤ÀªR¡v¡ÐDEA¤èªk¨Óµû¦ô¦h¤¸²£¥X»P§ë¤J²£·~¤§¸gÀç®Ä²v®É¡A¦p¦ó¿ï¨ú¾A·í¤§µû¦ôÅܼƫh·N¨£¤Àª[¡C¦]¦¹¥»¤å±N°w¹ï¤£¦P¾ÇªÌ¤§½×ÂIÂk¯Ç¤ÀªR¡A¨Ã´£¥X¥»¬ã¨s©Ò¿ï¨ú¤§¥N²zÅܼơC³Ì«á±N¦³ÃöªÑÅvµ²ºc¹ï©ó¹ØÀI¤½¥q¸gÀç¤è-±¤§¼vÅTªº¬ã¨sµÛ§@¡A¤@¨Ö§@¦^ÅU»P¾ã²z¡C
8
²Ä¤@¸`
¹ØÀI·~¸gÀçÁZ®Ä¤§²z½×¤Î¤åÄm±´°Q
¤@¡B ¸gÀçÁZ®Äªº©w¸q»P-«-n©Ê
¥ø·~ÁZ®Ä©M²Õ´ÁZ®Ä©Ò°Q½×ªº½d³òÁöµM¤£¦P¡A¦ý¬O-Y±N¥ø·~µø¬°¤@²Õ´¨Ó¬Ý¡A¨âªÌ¶¡«K¨S¦³¥ô¦óªº®t²§¡C¦]¦¹¾ÇªÌ±`±N¨âªÌ·í§@¦P¤@¥ó¨Æ±¡¨Ó°Q½×¡]³¯³Õµa¡A¥Á77¡¡^C¦¹¥~¡AÁZ®Ä¤§µû¦ô¥ç¥i¥Ñ-Ó¤H-±»P²Õ´-±¨Ó¬Ý¡A¬G¸gÀçÁZ®Ä¬O-Ó¤H»P²Õ´¤O¶q¬Û¤¬¼vÅT¤§²£¥Xµ²ªG¡A§Y-Ó¤H¤u§@¦æ¬°¤§ªø´Á¨ãÅéªí²{´N¬O²Õ´¾ãÅ骺ÁZ®Ä¡]ªL±Ò²l¡A¥Á76¡C¡^
¥ø·~©Î²Õ´©Ò°l¨Dªº¥Ø¼Ð¦b©ó¸gÀçÁZ®Äªº´£°ª¡A³o¤£¶È¬OºÞ²zªÌ§V¤O°l¨Dªº¥Ø¼Ð¡A¥ç¬O¥ø·~¥Ø¼Ð¹F¦¨ªºÁ`Åéªí²{¡CFerrel¡]1929¡^»{¬°ÁZ®ÄÀ³¥]¬A³Ð·s¡B½Ä¬ðªº´î¤Ö¡B®Äeffectiveness¯à¡]¡^¡B®Ä²v¡]efficiency¡¡^B¤u§@º¡·N»P-û¤u¤h®ð¡F¦ÓKatzel (1975)«h¥D±i®Ä¯àÀ³¥]¬AÁZ®Ä¡B¥Í²£¤O¡BÀò§Q¯à¤O¡FKast (1979)»{¬°ÁZ®ÄÀ³¥]§t®ÄªG¡]effect¡¡^B®Ä²v¡B²Õ´¦¨-ûº¡¨¬¡FAnderson (1988)»{¬°ÁZ®ÄÀ³¥]¬A¤TºØ¼Ð·Ç¡A§Y®Ä²v¡Bº¡·Nµ{«×¡B¾AÀ³¤O»P®Ä¯à¡]¬x¤d´f¡A¥Á82¡¡^C¥Ñ¦¹¥i¨£¡A¾ÇªÌ¦bÁZ®Äªº¤º²[¤W´¶¹M¦s¦³·N¨£¤Àª[ªº²{¶H¡C
¹ï©ó¡uÁZ®Ä¡]¡vperformance¡^¤@µü¡ASzilagyi (1984)±N¤§µø¬°¥Î¨Ó®i²{²Õ´¬¡°Êµ²ªGªº¤@§¹¾ã·§©À¡A®Ä²v»P®Ä¯à¬°ÁZ®Äªº¦¸¯Å²Õ¦¨¤¸¯À¡C¥ÑSzilagyi©Ò´£¥XªººÞ²zÁZ®Ä¬[ºc¡A¥iÁA¸ÑÁZ®Ä¤ÀªR¥i¹B¥Î¦h¤¸·Ç«h¡A¦Ò¶q¥D«ÈÆ[¤Î©w¶q¡B©w©Êªº¦]¯À¡A¹ï-Ó¤H¸sÅé²Õ´¤D¦ÜªÀ·|µ¥¼h¦¸¡A¶i¦æªø¡B¤¤¡Bµu´Áªº¤ÀªR¡C¤j³¡¤À¬ã¨sªÌ¹ï©ó¹ØÀI¤½¥q¤§¤ÀªR¼h¦¸ÄÝ©ó²Õ´-±¡A¤S¹ØÀI¤½¥qªº¸gÀçÁZ®Ä¬O¸gÀç»P·~°È±À°Ê¤§µ²ªG¡A¦]¦Ó¬O¤@ºØ«ÈÆ[¤§¦s¦b¡A¦P®É¤S¬OºÞ²zªÌ»P«O¤á¤j²³¤ß¥Ø¤¤»{©w¤§º¡·Nµ{«×ªº¥DÆ[§PÂ_¡C©Ò¥H¹ØÀI¤½¥qªº¸gÀçÁZ®Ä¬O¬J«ÈÆ[¥B¥DÆ[ªº¦s¦b¡A¬O¤ñ¸û¹ï·Ó-p¹º»P´Á±æ¤ô·Ç¦Ó±o¨ìªºµ²ªG§PÂ_¡A¦]¦¹¥¦¬O¬Û¹ïªº¦Ó«Dµ´¹ïªº¡]¾G¨q®S¡A¥Á85¡C¡^
9
¤G¡B ¹ØÀI·~¤§¸gÀçÁZ®Ä«ü¼Ð
¹ØÀI·~¤§¸gÀç§Þ³N¡B¸gÀç¤è¦¡¤£¶È»P¤@¯ë²£·~®t²§·¥¤j¡A¥ç»P¨ä¥Lª÷¿ÄªA°È·~¬Æ¦Ü²£ÀI·~¦³©Ò¤£¦P¡F¨ä-ì¦]¤£¥~¥G¬°¡G¹ØÀI«´¬ù´Á¶¡ªø¡B¦º¤`²v»P´Ý¯e²v¦]©Ó«O±Ú¸s¤§¤£¦P¦Ó®t²§»á¤j¡]¨Ò¡G¦¸¼Ð·ÇÅé¡^B¹ØÀI¤½¥q¤§-t¶Å¡u¦sÄò´Á¶¡¡]¡v
duration¡^¦ôºâ§xÃø¡B¹D¼w¦MÀI¸û°ª¥H
¤Î¹ØÀI·~°Èªº±À¼s»Ý¥õ¿à¤j¶q¤§¦æ¾P¤H-û¡A²£¥Í¤F¥tºØ¡u¥N²z°ÝÃD¡v¡]«OÀI¤½¥q¡Ð·~°È-û¡Ð«O¤á¡C¡^
¦]¦¹¡A©ó¿Å¶q¹ØÀI¤½¥q¤§¸gÀçÁZ®Ä®É©Ò±Ä¥Î¤§¨Ì¾Ú¡Aµ´¤£¦P©ó¤@¯ë²£·~©Ò±Ä¥Î¤§·|-p¤Î°]°È«ü¼Ð¡A¦p¡GÀ禬²bÃB¡Bµ|«e¯Â¯q¡B²b-ȳø¹S²v¡B¸ê²£³ø¹S²v¡BÀ禬¦¨ªø²vµ¥µû¦ô¶µ¥Ø¡F¦Ó¥Ø«e°ê¤º¤§¡u¤H¹Ø«OÀI°Ó·~¦P·~¤½·|¡v©Ò½s¦L¤§¡u¤H¹Ø«OÀI·~°È²Î-p¦~³ø¡v¤¤¥Î©ó¿Å¶q¹ØÀI¤½¥q¸gÀ禨ÁZ¤§«ü¼Ð¦³¥|¡G·s«´¬ù¡B¦³®Ä«´¬ù¡B«O¶O¦¬¤J¤Î«OÀIµ¹¥I¡F¦ý²`¨s¦¹¥|¶µ«ü¼Ð¨äµû¦ô¤§¼Ð·Ç°¾-«¦b¡u²£¥X-±¡v¡A¹ï©ó¤½¥q¦¨¥ß¤§¦~¼Æ¡B¤½¥q¤§³W¼Ò¡B¤º¥~¶Ô¤H¼Æ¡BÀç·~¶O¥Î¦h¹èµ¥¡u§ë¤J-±¡v¶µ¥Ø¡A¬Ò¥¼¯Ç¤J¿Å¶q¶µ¥Ø§@¤@¬Û¹ï©Êªº¤ñ¸û¡A¦p¦¹¤ù-±¤§¿Å¶qµ²ªG±N¹ï·s¶i·~ªÌ·¥¬°¤£§Q¡A¦Ó¥¢«o¤F¯u¥¿¿Å¶qÁZ®Ä©Ò»Ý¹F¨ìªº¤½¥-¡B¤½¥¿¤Î«ÈÆ[©Ê¡C¦³Å²©ó¦¹¡A¥»¬ã¨s±N¥H¸gÀپǤ¤ªº¦U¶µ¡u®Ä²v¡]¡vefficiency¡^
«ü¼Ð¡A¨Ó¥N´À¹L¥h¾ÇªÌ©ÒºD¥Îªº°]°È-±©Î·|-p-±¤§¡uÁZ®Ä¡v¡]performance¡^«ü¼Ð¡Aµû¦ôªº¨Ì¾Ú¬°¦P®É±N¡u²£¥X¡v¤Î¡u§ë¤J¡v¬Ò¯Ç¤J¦Ò¶qªº¡u®Ä²v«e½tªk¡v¡A¦Ó©ó¦¹¬Û¹ï¿Å¶q¤§¤èªk¤U¡A¤£½×¬O·s·~ªÌ¡A¥ç¤£½×¨ä¤½¥q³W¼Ò¤§¤j¤p¡A¬Ò¥H¡u§ë¤J²£¥X¡v¤§¤ñ¨Ò¬O§_¯à¹F¨ì³Ì¾A»P§_¡A¦Ó¨M©w¨ä¡u®Ä²v¤ô·Ç¡v¡F¦ÓÂǦ¹¤èªkµû¦ô¸gÀç®Ä²v¡A¤è¯à¹F¨ì¤½¥-¦X²z¤§ºë¯«
10
¤T¡B ¹êµý¤åÄm
Pritchett (1971)¥H¬ü°ê¯Ã¬ù¦{¿ï¨ú¤T¤Q®a¹ØÀI¤½¥q¬°¬ã¨s½d³ò¡A¥H¨ä¹ê»Ú¸gÀç¶O¥Î©M¸gÀç¶O¥ÎÁ`©Mªº¤ñ-È¡]§Ytotal actual operation expense/total standard operation expense¡A²ºÙA/S-È ¡^A§@¬°¹ØÀI¤½¥q¾ãÅé¸gÀç®Ä²vªº¿Å¶q¼Ð·Ç¡C¨ä¤¤¹ê»Ú¸gÀç¶O¥Î¥]¬A¹ØÀI¤½¥q¦~«×³øªí¤¤©ÒÅã¥Üªº¦U¶µ¶O¥Î¡A¨Ò¦p¯²ª÷¶O¥Î¡B§é¡BÁ~¸ê¡B¦þª÷µ¥¶O¥ÎªºÁ`©M¡A¼Ð·Ç¸gÅç¶O¥Î«h¥Ñ¦U¹ØÀI¤½¥q¸Ó¦~«×¤º·s«´¬ù¥ó¼Æ¡BÄò¦~«×«´¬ù¥ó¼Æ¥H¤Î«OÀIª÷ÃB¦h¹èµ¥¸ê®Æ¡A-¼¤W¬Û¹ïÀ³ªº¼Ð·Ç¶O¥Î¦]¤l¦A¤©¥H¥[Á`¦Ó±o¡F¦Ó¦¹¬ã¨sµo²{¦¹¤T¤Q®a¹ØÀI¤½¥qªºA/S-ȤÀ§G¦b0.7636¨ì1.3520¤§¶¡¡F¦P®É¨ÌÁ`©Ó«Oª÷ÃB¬°¼Ð·Ç¡A±N¦¹¤T¤Q®a¹ØÀI¤½¥q¤À¦¨¤p¡B¤¤¡B¤j¥H¤Î¯S¤j¥|ºØ³W¼Ò¡Aµo²{A/S-ÈÀH³W¼ÒÂX¤j¦Ó§e²{´î¤Öªº²{¶H¡C
Michael¡BSomeshwar and Randall (1985)¥H¥[®³¤j¹ØÀI·~¤§¥Í²£¤O¡B³W¼Ò¸gÀ٤Χ޳N¶i¨B¤@¤å¸Õ¹Ï§ä¥X§ï¨}¥Í²£¤O¤§¥D-n¨Ó·½¡A¥H-Ó¤HÀI»P¹ÎÅéÀI¤§ªì¦~«×¤ÎÄò¦~«×«O¶O¦¬¤J¡B¦~ª÷«OÀI¤§«O¶O¦¬¤J¡B¶U´Ú»P©T©w¸ê²£«O³æ¶U´Úµ¥¬°²£¥X¡A¥H¨ä³æ¦ì¦¨¥»©Î¬Y¤@Åv-«¤§ª÷ÃB¬°§ë¤J¡C¨äµ²ªGµo²{¥Í²£¤O¦¨ªøªº-«-n¨Ó·½¬°§Þ³N¶i¨B¡C
Praetz (1981)¥H¿D¬w¹ØÀI·~¬°¹ï¶H±´°Q¨ä³W¼Ò¸gÀÙ¤§ÃÒ¾Ú¡A¨ä¥HÁ`«O¶O¦¬¤J¡BÁ`¦¨¥»¡]¦þª÷¡ÏÁ~¸ê¡Ï¨ä¥L¶O¥Î¡^µ¥¬°ÅܼơC
Reece (1991)¥H«O¶O²v¡B²z½ß²v¡B·Ç³Æª÷¤ñ²v¡B«O³æ¶U´Ú³ø¹S²v¡B¸ê²£³ø¹S²v¬°Åܼƨӱ´°Q¬ü°ê¹ØÀI·~ªº²£¥X»ù®æÅܤƱ¡§Î¡CKelner and Mathewson (1983) ¥H«O³æ¼Æ¥Ø¬°²£¥X¡FFields and Murphy (1989)«h¥H¦þª÷¬°²£¥X¡C¡]¾G¨q®S,¥Á85¡^
Fecher et al. (1993) ¥Hªk°ê¹Ò¤º84®a¹ØÀI¤½¥q¤Î243®a«D¹ØÀI¤½¥q¬°¬ã¨s¹ï¶H¶i¦æ¬Û¹ï¥Í²£®Ä²v¤§¬ã¨s¡A¨Ã¨Ï¥ÎµL¥À¼Æªº¸ê®Æ¥]µ¸¤ÀªRªk»P¦³¥À¼Æªº³Ì¤j·§¦ü¤èªk¥[¥H¤ñ¸û¡A¬ã¨sµo²{¨âºØ¤èªk¤§µû¦ôµ²
11
ªG¶¡¦s¦³°ª«×ªº¬ÛÃö¡A¥B¦³³\\¦hµL®Ä²vªº¤½¥q´²¶Ã¤À§G¡A¦¹¤@Â÷´²±¡§Î¥iÂǥѱ±¨î¤½¥q³W¼Ò¡B©Ò¦³Åv¡B¦A§ë«O²v¤Î²z½ß²v¤§Åܲ§¦Ó§ïµ½¡C
12
²Ä¤G¸`
¥N²z°ÝÃD»PªÑÅvµ²ºc
¤@¡B ¥N²z°ÝÃDªº·½°_
Ross (1973)«ü¥X¥N²zÃö«Y¬O¤HÃþªÀ·|¤¬°Ê¤¤³Ì¥j¦Ñ¥B³Ì³q±`ªº¼Ò¦¡¤§¤@¡A·í¤@-Ó¤H¡]«ü¥N²z¤H¡Aagent¡^¦b¬Y¤@½d³ò¤º¥Nªí¥t¤@¤H¡]«ü¥D²z¤H¡Aprincipal¡^°µ¨Mµ¦®É«K²£¥Í¤F¥N²zÃö«Y¡C¨ä¹ê¦-¦b1932¦~Berle and Meansªº¬ã¨s«Kµo²{ÀHµÛ¸gÀÙ¡B¤å¤Æ¡BªÀ·|µ¥¦U¤è-±ªºÅܾE¡A¤½¥qªº¸gÀçµ²ºc¥Hº¥ÁͦV©Ò¦³Åv»P¸gÀç±±¨îÅv¤ÀÂ÷ªº«¬ºA¡C¦b¦¹ºØ¸gÀ竬ºA¤U¤½¥q¸g²z¤H¦³»¤¦]¤£¦A¥H¤½¥q§Q¯q·¥¤j¤Æ¬°¨ä²×·¥¥Øªº¡A¦Ó¦³°¾Â÷¦¹¥Øªºªº¦Û§Q¦æ¬°²£¥Í
°ê¤º¾ÇªÌªL¬³Î]¡]¥Á79¡^¦b¨äµÛ§@¤¤Âk¯Ç¾ÇªÌ·N¨£¡A´£¥X¤@-Ó¥ø·~¥Ø¼Ðªº¤ÀªR©Ê¬[ºc¡C¨ä¬[ºcÅã¥Ü¡A©Ò¦³ÅvªÌ¡]ªÑªF¡^°l¨D°]´I·¥¤j¤Æ¡A·N§Y°l¨DªÑ»ù·¥¤j¤Æ¡F¦ÓºÞ²z±±¨îÅv¤H¡]ºÞ²zªÌ¡^°l¨D¥»¨-®Ä¥Î·¥¤j¤Æ¡A¨ä¥Ø¼Ð©Î³\\¬O©Ò¿×ºÞ²zªÌ¹ï¤u§@ªºº¡·N¡A©Î³\\¬O©Ò¿×¥ø·~«ùÄòªº°·±d»P¬¡¤O¡A©Î³\\¬O¾P°âÃB·¥¤j¤Æ¡C¦b³o¨ä¤¤«K¦s¦bµÛ¥N²z°ÝÃD¡C
¤G¡B ¥N²z²z½×
¥N²z²z½×©Ò-n¸Ñ¨Mªº¤D¬O¥N²z°ÝÃD¡A¦Ó¥N²z°ÝÃD¤D¬O¦]¥N²zÃö«Y©Ò²£¥Í¡C¨ÌJensen and Meckling (1976)ªºÆ[ÂI¡A²Õ´¤D¦U²Õ¦¨¥÷¤¡l]¥]¬A©Ò¦³ªÌ¡BºÞ²zªÌ¡B-û¤uµ¥¶¡¡¡^A¥¿¦¡»P«D¥¿¦¡«´¬ùªºÁpµ²ÂI¡A¤½¥q¤º³¡¦U²Õ¦¨¥÷¤l´N¬O¨Ì¿à¤£¦Pªº«´¬ùÃö«Y¦Óºò±KÁpµ²¡A¦Ó¥Ñ¦¹²£¥Íªº«´¬ù¦¨¥»¡A¥ç¬O¾É-P¤½¥q¥Í²£¡B°]°È¡B·|-p¦U¬Fµ¦¦³©Ò®t²§ªº-«-n¸ÑÄÀ¦]¯À¡A
¬JµM¤½¥q¬O¥Ñ¦UºØ«´¬ùÃö«Y¬[ºc¦Ó¦¨¡A¨º»ò¦b«´¬ù¹ÎÅé¦s¦b¥Ø¼Ð
13
½Ä¬ð»P¦Û§Q¦æ¬°ªº«e´£°²³]¤U¡A¥Ñ¦U¶µ«´¬ù©w¸qªº¥N²zÃö«Y©Ò²£¥Íªº¥N²z°ÝÃD«K¤£¥iÁקK¡A®Ú¾Ú
Jensen and Meckling (1976)ªº©w¸q¡A¥N²z
Ãö«Y¤D¦]¤@¦ì©Î¦h¦ì¥D²z¤H¡]principal¡^¶±¥Î¨Ã±ÂÅvµ¹¥t¤@¦ì¥N²z¤H¡]agent¡^¥N¨ä¦æ¨Ï¬Y¯S©w¦æ°Ê¡A©¼¦¹¶¡©Ò¦s¦bªº«´¬ùÃö«Y¡C¦]¦¹¡A·í´¤¦³¦Ê¤À¤§¦ÊªÑÅv¤§©Ò¦³ªÌ-ݺ޲zªÌ¡A¬°¦]À³¤½¥qÀç¹B¸êª÷»Ý¨D¦ÓÁ|¶Å©Îµo¦æÃÒ¨é¤À´²ªÑÅv®É¡AºÞ²zªÌ»P¥~³¡ªÑªF¡B¶ÅÅv¤H¤§¶¡ªº¥N²z°ÝÃD©ó²j§Î¦¨¡C
Jensen and Meckling»{¬°¥N²z«´¬ù©Ò¾É-Pªº½Ä¬ð¸sÅ馳¤G¡G¤@¬°ºÞ²zªÌ»PªÑªF¶¡ªº½Ä¬ð¡F¥t¤@¬°ªÑªF»P¶ÅÅv¤H¶¡ªº½Ä¬ð¡C«eªÌ±N¾É-PÅv¯q¥N²z¦¨¥»¡A¨ä¦¨¥»¨Ó¦Û«ù¦³³¡¤ÀªÑÅvªº©Ò¦³ªÌ-ݸgÀçªÌ©Ò¾É-Pªº¯SÅv®ø¶O¡]perquisite consumption¡^©M¿Ä¸ê¶R¤U¡]leverage buyout¡^°ÝÃD¡F«áªÌ¾É-P-t¶Å¥N²z¦¨¥»¡A¨ä¦¨¥»¨Ó¦Û©ó©Ò¦³ªÌ-ݺ޲zªº¯SÅv®ø¶O¡B¯}²£¬ÛÃö¦¨¥»©M-t¶Å¦³Ãö¤§°Ê¾÷°ÝÃD¡CBarnea¡BHaugen and Senbet (1981)»{¬°°£¤F¤W-z¨Ó·½¤§¥~¡A©|¦³¸ê°T¤£¹ïºÙ¤Î¦¸¨Îªº§ë¸ê¨Mµ¦°ÝÃD¡CJensen (1986)«á¨Ó¤S´£¥X¤F¦Û¥Ñ²{ª÷¬y¶q¡]Free Cash Flow¡^ªº¥N²z°ÝÃD¡C¥t¥~¦bTitmann (1984)ªº¬ã¨s¤¤»{¬°¡A¥N²z°ÝÃD¨Ã¤£--©ó-t¶Å¤ÎÅv¯qªº¥N²z¦¨¥»¡A¦Ó´£¥X¤F¤½¥q»PÅU«È¡B¤½¥q»P-û¤u¤§¶¡ªº¥N²z°ÝÃD¡C¨ä¤¤Åv¯q¥N²z¦¨¥»«Y®Ú¾ÚJensen and Meckling (1976)ªº©w¸q¡A¥]¬A¤U¦C¤T¶µ¡G
1.¥D²z¤HºÊ·þ¥N²z¤H¨Mµ¦©Ò²£¥Íªº¦U¶µºÊ·þ¶O¥Î¡C 2.¥N²z¤H¬°¤F¨Ï¥D²z¤H¦w¤ß©Ò²£¥Íªº¬ù§ô¶O¥Î¡C
3.¥Ñ©ó¥D²z¤H»P¥N²z¤H¤§¶¡¤´¦s¦³¥¼¸Ñ¨Mªº§Q¯q½Ä¬ð¡A¨Ï±o¥N²z¤H¥¼¯à°µ¥X¨Ï¥D²z¤HºÖ§Q³Ì¤j¤§¨Mµ¦¡A¨ä©Ò²£¥Íªº³Ñ¾l·l¥¢¡C
¤T¡B ¸Ñ¨M¥N²z°ÝÃD¤§¾÷¨î
¬°¸Ñ¨MªÑªF©MºÞ²z·í§½¶¡ªº¥N²z°ÝÃD¡A³¯¶©ÄQ¡]¥Á81¡^¦b¨äµÛ
14
§@¤¤´£¨ì¦³¥H¤U¨âºØ·¥ºÝªº°µªk¡]¡G
1¡^±N¥Iµ¹ºÞ²z·í§½ªºÁ~¹S¥þ³¡¥Ñ
¤½¥qªÑ²¼ºc¦¨¡A¦ý¤½¥q¥i¯à«ÜÃø§ä¨ìÄ@·N±µ¨ü¤W-z±ø¥óªººÞ²z¤H¤~¡F¡]2¡^¥ÑªÑªF±K¤ÁºÊ·þºÞ²z·í§½ªº¦UºØ¦æ°Ê¡A¦ý¦¹ºØ§@ªkªººÊ·þ¦¨¥»°ª¡A¤]¯Ê¥F®Ä²v¡C¦]¦¹¡A¸û¨Îªº¸Ñ¨M¤è¦¡À³¬O±Ä¨ú¨âºØ±¹¬I¡A¤@¤è-±ÅýºÞ²z·í§½ªºÁ~¹S»P¤½¥qªº¸gÀçÁZ®Ä³sµ²¡A¥t¤@¤è-±¤]«Ø¥ß¨}¦nªººÊ±±¨t²Î¡A¥HºÊ·þºÞ²z·í§½ªº¦æ°Ê¡C
¸Ñ¨MªÑªF©MºÞ²z·í§½¶¡ªºÅv¯q¥N²z°ÝÃD¹L¥h¦³³\\¦hªº¾ÇªÌ´£¥X¦UºØ¸Ñ¨Mª¾¹Dºî¦X¦U®a½×ÂI¥D-n¥]¬A¥H¤Uªº¤è¦¡
¡]¤@¡^ ´£°ªºÞ²zªÌªº«ùªÑ¤ñ²v
§Q¯q¦¬ÀÄ°²»¡¶É¦V©ó´£°ªºÞ²zªÌªº«ùªÑ¤ñ²v¡A¥i¨ÏºÞ²zªÌ©MªÑªF¨âªÌ¶¡ªº§Q¯q¸û¬°¤@-P¡A¦]¦Ó-°§C¥N²z¦¨¥»¡C¦ý´£°ªºÞ²zªÌªº¤½¥q´¶³qªÑ«ù¦³¤ñ¨Ò¨Ã¤£©y¤Ó°ª¡A§_«hºÞ²zªÌ·|¦]«ù¦³¬Û·í¤ñ¨Òªº¤½¥qªÑÅv¡A¦Ó¯à¹ê½è¦³®Ä¦a´x´¤¤½¥q±±¨îÅv®É¡A¨ä·|°l¨D¦Û¤vªº§Q¯q¡A¦Ó¸û¤£·|¦b·N¥~¨ÓªººÊ·þ»P¥«³õ¾÷¯à¡A¨Ã¥BºÞ²zªÌ·|¦]¥»¨-°]´I¦h¨¤¤Æªºµ{«×-°§C¡A¶i¦Ó-n¨D§ó¦hªº¸ÉÀv¡A³y¦¨¥ø·~ÃB¥~-t¾á¡C
¡]¤G¡^¸³¨Æ·|ªººÊ±±
Fama (1980)¡BWilliamson (1983)¡BMorck¡BShleifer and Vishny (1988)¡B¶Àà±¥ú¡]¥Á82¡¡^Bªô¼z§u¡]¥Á83¡^©MªL¨|¶®¡]¥Á83¡^µ¥¤H§¡»{¬°¡A¸³¨Æ·|¨ã¦³¸Ñ¨M¥N²z°ÝÃDªº¾÷¯à¡C¨ä¤¤Williamson´£¥X--´À¥N©Ê°²»¡¡]substitution hypothesis¡¡^A»{¬°¸³¨Æ·|ªº¥\\¯à©MÁʨ֫¯٪º¥\\¯à¨âªÌ-ݨ㦳´À¥N©Ê¡A¦b¸ê¥»¥«³õ©Î¤H¤O¥«³õ¥\\¯àµLªkµo´§ªº¦a¤è¡A¸³¨Æ·|±N§êºt§ó-«-nªº¥\\¯à¡C¦ÓFama (1980)§ó±j½Õ¸³¨Æ·|ªº¥D-nÀuÂI¦b©ó¡A¥¦¬O¤@-Ó¸û§C¦¨¥»ªº±±¨î¾÷¨î¡C
¡]¤T¡^ ºÞ²z¿EÀy-p¹º
¤½¥q¦b¹ê¬IºÞ²z¿EÀy-p¹º®É¡A±`¥Îªº¿EÀy¤u¨ã¦³ªÑ²¼ÁʶR¿ï¾ÜÅv¡]stock option¡^»PÁZ®ÄªÑ¡]performance share¡¡^C¦¹ºØ-p¹º¤D¬O±N¥Iµ¹ºÞ²z¤H-ûªºÁ~¹S»P¤½¥qªºÁZ®Äµ²¦X¦b¤@°_¡A¥H¿EÀyºÞ²z¤H-û¡A¨Ï¨ä§ó
15
Ä@·N±Ä¨ú¨º¨Ç¯à´£°ª¤½¥qªÑ»ùªº¦æ°Ê¡C¦¹-p¹º¤§¥Î·N¦b¨ÏºÞ²zªÌ»PªÑªF§Q¯q¤@-P¡AÁקK¥Ø¼Ð¤£¤@-P©Ò³y¦¨ªº¥N²z°ÝÃD¡A¦b
Lewellen (1971)
©MEisenhard (1989)ªº¬ã¨s¤¤§¡µo²{¡A¨Ï¥Î³o¨Ç¿EÀy¤u¨ã¡A¥i¨ÏºÞ²zªÌ§óÄ@·N±Ä¨ú¯à´£°ª¤½¥q»ù-Ȫº¦æ°Ê¡C
¥|¡B ªÑÅvµ²ºc»P¸gÀçÁZ®Ä
¦-¦b1932¦~Berle and Means´£¥X©Ò¦³Åv»P¸gÀçÅv¤ÀÂ÷ªº·§©À«á¡A¥ø·~¸gÀçªÌ»PªÑªF¤§¶¡ªº§Q¯q½Ä¬ð¡A¹E¦¨¬°³Æ¨üª§Ä³ªºµJÂI¡A»{¬°¥ø·~©Ò¦³Åv»P¸gÀçÅv·U«¬¤À´²¡A©Ò¦³ªÌ»P¸gÀçªÌªº½Ä¬ð·|ÀH¤§¼W¥[¡C¹L¥h¦³¾ÇªÌ»{¬°ªÑÅv¤Ó¹L¤À´²¡A±N¨Ï±o¸g²z¤H¨ü¨ì¥ø·~±±¨îªºµ{«×¤U-°¡A¶i¦Ó·|¼vÅT¤½¥q»ù-È¡C¦ÓJenson«h«ü¥X¸g²z¤H¨Ã¤£¾Ö¦³³Ñ¾l¨DÀvÅv¡A¤]¤£¥²¤À¾á-·ÀI³d¥ô¡A¬G¤£·|¿n·¥°l¨D¤½¥q»ù-È·¥¤j¡A¦Ó¥u°l¨D¥»¨-ªº®Ä¥Î·¥¤j¡CÃö©óªÑÅvµ²ºc©M¤½¥q¸gÀçÁZ®Ä¶¡¤§Ãö«Y¡A°ê¤º¥~¦³³\\¦h¾ÇªÌ§@¹L¬ÛÃö¬ã¨s¡A¦ý¬O¨ä¬Ýªk«o¬Û·í¤£¤@-P¡A¤j-P¤W¥i¥H¤À¬°¤U¦C¤TºØ¬Ýªk¡G
¡]¤@¡^ §Q¯q¦¬ÀÄ°²»¡¡]Convergence of interest hypothesis¡^
Jensen and Mekling (1976)´£¥X¡u§Q¯q¦¬ÀÄ°²»¡¡¡vA¥L-Ì»{¬°ªÑÅv¶V¶°¤¤¦bºÞ²zªÌ¤â¤¤¡AºÞ²zªÌ¤ä¥X°¾¦n¦æ¬°©Ò³y¦¨ªº¥ø·~°]´I·l¥¢¡A±N¤j³¡¤À¥ÑºÞ²zªÌ©Ó¾á¡F¦]¦¹ºÞ²zªÌªº¦æ¬°±NÁÍ©ó¦X²z¤Æ¡A¥H°l¨D¤½¥q»ù-È·¥¤j¤Æ¡F-YªÑÅv¶°¤¤©ó¥~³¡¸³¨Æ©Î¤jªÑªF¤â¤¤¡A¥L-Ì·|¦³¸û¤jªº»¤¦]¥hºÊ±±ºÞ²zªÌ¡A¨ÏºÞ²z®Ä²v´£¤É¡A¼W¥[¤½¥q¸gÀçÁZ®Ä¡F¦]¦¹¥»°²»¡¤§½×ÂI¬°¤½¥qªÑÅv·U¶°¤¤¡A·U¯à´£¤É¸gÀçÁZ®Ä¡C
¡]¤G¡^ ¾d©T©Ê°²»¡¡]Entrenchment hypothesis¡^
¦¹½×ÂI»{¬°¸³¨Æ·|°ò©ó¥»¨-¡u¾¦ì¦w¥þ©Ê¡vªº¦Ò¶q¡A©¹©¹·|
16
²£¥Í¤@¨Ç¡u¤Ï±µºÞ¦æ¬°¡¡vA¨Ò¦p§_¨M¹ïªÑªF¦³§Qªº¡]
¡uÁʨִ£Ä³®×¡v
merger proposal¡¡^A©Îªýê¥i¨Ï¤½¥qªÑ»ù¤W¤Éªº¡uªÑÅv¦¬Áʮס]¡vtender
offer¡¡^A¦]¦¹-YªÑÅv¶V¶°¤¤©ó¸³¨Æ·|©Î¤Ö¼Æ¤jªÑªF¤â¤¤¡A³oºØ¤Ï±µºÞ¦æ¬°¦¨¥\\ªº¥i¯à©Ê¶V¤j¡A¦]¦¹ºÞ²zªÌÂp¾¦æ¬°¥i±o¨ì§ó¤jªº«O»Ù¡A¤ä¥X°¾¦n¦æ¬°±N§óÄY-«¡A¥ø·~ÁZ®Ä¦ÛµM§C¸¨¡C
¡]¤T¡^ ªÑÅvµ²ºc©M¤½¥q¸gÀçÁZ®ÄµLÃö½×
Fama (1980)¥H¥«³õªºÆ[ÂI¨Ó¸ÑÄÀºÞ²zªÌªº¥N²z°ÝÃD¡C·í¸ê¥»¥«³õ¨ã®Ä²v©Ê¡A¥B¥~³¡ºÞ²z¤H¤O¥«³õ¬°§¹¥þÄvª§¥«³õ¡A¦¹®É¤½¥qªº¸gÀçÁZ®Ä·|§¹¥þ³Q¤Ï¬M¦bªÑ»ù¤W¡A¥~³¡ºÞ²zªÌ³Ò°Ê¥«³õ·|µ¹¤©À£¤O-¢¨Ï¤½¥q¥H¸gÀçÁZ®Ä¨Ó¨M©wºÞ²zªÌªºÁ~¸ê¡A©Ò¥HºÞ²zªÌ·|§ó-P¤O©ó¤½¥qÁZ®Äªº´£¤É¡A¥L»{¬°¤½¥qªºÁZ®Ä¥Ñ¥~³¡ºÞ²z¤H¤O¥«³õ¨M©w¡A»PªÑÅvµ²ºcµLÃö¡C
17
²Ä¤T¸`
Á~¹S¬ÛÃö¤åÄm
¤@¡B Á~¹Sªº·N¸q
©Ò¿×Á~¹S¬O«ü¥ø·~¹ï©ó-û¤u©Ò´£¨Ñªº¤u§@³ø¹S¡A¹ï-û¤u¨Ó»¡³o¬O§V¤O©Ò±o¦ÛµM¬O¦h¦h¯qµ½¹ï¥ø·~¨Ó»¡³o¬O¸gÀ禨¥»ªº¤@³¡¥÷±ý§C·U¦n±qªÀ·|ªº¨¤«×¨Ó¬Ý«h¬OªÀ·|¸ê·½¤À°tªº¤â¬q¤@©w-n°l¨D¦X²z»{¬°Á~¹S¹ï¥ø·~¨ã¦³¤U¦Cªº¿n·¥·N¸q¡G
¡]¤@¡^ Á~¹S¥i¥H§l¤Þ¤H¤~¡G
¤@¯ë³Ò°ÊªÌ¤u§@ªº¥D-n-ì¦]¤§¤@´N¬O¨ú±oÁ~¹S¡A©Ò¥H¸û°ªªº¤ô·ÇªºÁ~¹S¥i¥H¯d¦í¦³Â÷¾·NÄ@ªº-û¤u¡A§ó¶i¦Ó¥i¥H§l¤Þ¥~³¡ªº-û¤u¨Ó¥ô¾¡C±q¤j³¡¤Àªº½Õ¬d¤¤Åã¥Ü¡AÁ~¹S¤£¤@©w¬O-û¤u¿ï¾Ü¤u§@ªº³Ì-«-n¦]¯À¡A¦ý¤jÅé¦Ó¨¥¡A³q±`¬O¥D-n¦]¯À¤§¤@¡C
¡]¤G¡^ Á~¹S¨ã¦³¿EÀy§@¥Î¡G
Á~¹S¤£¶È®ø·¥ªº§l¤Þ¦í-û¤u¡A´î¤Ö-û¤u¹ï¤u§@ªº¤£º¡¡A¦b¿n·¥ªº-n¨D¤W§ó¯à°µ¨ì«P¨Ï-û¤u§V¤O¬°¤½¥q®Ä¤O¡C¨Ì¾Ú¤ß²z¾Ç®aMaslawªº¡u»Ý¨D¼h¦¸²z½×¡v¡AÁ~¹S©Î³z¹LÁ~¹Sªº¹B¥Î¹ï-û¤u¦Ó¨¥¥i¥Hº¡¨¬¥Í²z¡B¦w¥þ¡BªÀ¥æ¡B¦Û´L©M¦Û§Ú¹ê²{µ¥¼sªxªº»Ý¨D¡C
¡]¤T¡^ Á~¹S¨î«×·|¼vÅT¥ø·~¤å¤Æ¡G
Á~¹Sµ¹¥I¨î«×¥i¥H±j¤Æ©MÂç²M²Õ´µ²ºc»P¥ø·~¤å¤Æ¡C±qÁ~¸êµ²ºc¤¤¥i¥Hª¾¹D©³Á~¡B¼úª÷©MºÖ§Qªº¬Û¹ï-«-n©Ê¡A¨ä¤¤§ó¤ÏÀ³¤F¥ø·~ªº¤å¤Æ¡C¦p¤é¥»¥ø·~ªºÁ~¹S¤¤¥-§¡¦³25%ªºÁZ®Ä¼úª÷¡A©Ò¥H·í¥ø·~-±Á{¸gÀÙ¤£´º®ð®É¡AÁ~¹S·|¦]²£«~¦Ó¦³¼u©ÊªºÅܤơA¤£-P²£¥Í¹ï¥Í²£¦¨¥»¤Ó¤jªº¼vÅT¡Aºû«ù²£«~¦b¥«³õ¤WªºÄvª§¤O¡C¦ý¬ü°ê¥ø·~¤§ÁZ®Ä¼úª÷¤@¯ë¶È¦û1%¡A¨Ï±oÁ~¹S¦b¦]À³¥«³õÅܰʮɲ£¥Í»ø©Tªº²{¶H¡A³y¦¨¥Í²£¦¨¥»ªº¤@¤j-t¾á¡]§d®aÁn¡A¥Á78¡C¡^
18
¤G¡B
°ª¶¥¥DºÞÁ~¹S¨î«×ªº¨M©w¦]¯À
¤½¥q°ª¶¥¥DºÞªºÁ~¹S¨î«×³q±`¬O¥Ñ¸³¨Æ·|¨M©w¡A¸³¨Æ·|³q±`¬O®Ú¾Ú¨ä¹ï°ª¶¥¥DºÞ¨¤¦âªº»{ª¾¤Î¨ä¹ï¿EÀyªº°²³]§@¬°¨î©w¤§¨Ì¾Ú¡A¦Ó³o¨Ç»{ª¾»P°²³]«h·|¨ü¨ì°ª¶¥¥DºÞ¥»¨-¤Î³\\¦h¥~¦b¦]¯À©Ò¼vÅT¡C°ê¤º¿½§»¼Ý¡]¥Á83¡^±N°ª¶¥ºÞ²zªÌÁ~¹S¨î«×ªº¼vÅT¦]¯À¤À¬°¡G»P¤½¥q¦³Ãö¤§¦]¯À¡B»PºÞ²zªÌ¦³Ãö¤§¦]¯À¥H¤Î¥~¬ÉÀô¹Ò¦]¯À¤T¤jÃþ¡F¥H¤U¬°¦¹¤@¬[ºc¤§¤Uªº±´°Q¤º®e¡C
¡]¤@¡^ »P¤½¥q¦³Ãöªº¦]¯À
1¡B¤½¥q³W¼Ò
±´°Q¤½¥q³W¼Ò»P°ª¶¥ºÞ²zÁ~¹Sªº¤åÄm¬Û·í¦h¡AÁöµM¦U¾ÇªÌ©Ò´£¥X¤§²z¥Ñ¤£¾¨¬Û¦P¡A¦ýµ²½×«o¤Q¤À¤@-P¡G¤½¥qªº³W¼Ò·U¤j¡A°ª¶¥¥DºÞªºÁ~¹S·U°ª¡C¹ï©ó¦¹¤@²{¶H¾ÇªÌ-̦³³\\¦hªº¸ÑÄÀ¡ASimon (1957)©MAgarwal (1981)»{¬°¤j¤½¥q¤¤¦³¸û¦hªº²Õ´¼h¯Å¡A©Ò¥H°ª¶¥¥DºÞ©ÒÀò±oªºÁ~¹S¬Û¹ï©ó¤p¤½¥q-n¨Ó±o¦h¡F¥ç¦³¾ÇªÌ»{¬°¡A¤j¤½¥qªº°ª¶¥¥DºÞ¥²¶·ºÊ·þ³\\¦h-«-n¸ê·½¡A¬Û¹ï©ó¤p¤½¥qªº°ª¶¥¥DºÞ¦Ó¨¥¡A¥L-̪º¨Mµ¦¦æ¬°Åã±o¸û¤p¤½¥qªº°ª¶¥¥DºÞ¨Ó±o-«-n¡A¬GÀ³µ¹¤©¸ûÀu´ìÁ~¹S¡C
2¡B¤½¥q¸gÀçÁZ®Ä
¥N²z²z½×«Øij¦b¨î©w°ª¶¥¥DºÞÁ~¹S¨Mµ¦¤§®É¡AÀ³±N¤½¥q¸gÀçÁZ®Ä¯Ç¤J¦Ò¶q¦]¯À¡A¥H¸Ñ¨M¥N²z°ÝÃD¡FµM¦Ó¡]Murphy¡A1985¡^¸g¥Ñ¾îÂ_-±¹êµý¤ÀªRªºµ²ªG¤½¥q¸gÀçÁZ®Ä»P°ª¶¥¥DºÞÁ~¹Sªº¬ÛÃöµ{«×¤£¤j¡F¦ý¦¹¤@²{¶H¥i¯àÂk¨s¤§-ì¦]¬°¡GÁ~¹SÀ³¬°¤½¥q¹ï°ª¶¥¥DºÞ¹L¥h¸gÀçÁZ®Ä¤§¼úÀy¡AµM¦Ó¾ÇªÌ±q¨ÆÁ~¹S»PÁZ®ÄÃö«Y¤§¬ã¨s®É¡A¤j¦h¥H
19
Á~¹S¤ô·Ç©M¥Ø«e¤§ÁZ®Ä¥[¥H¤ñ¸û¡A¦]¦¹·|²£¥Í°¾»~¤§¬ã¨sµ²ªG¡C
3¡B¤½¥q¦h¨¤¤Æªºµ{«×
Agarwal¡]1981¡^»{¬°¡A§Y¨Ï¦b®ø°£¤½¥q³W¼Òªº¼vÅT«á¡A¦³¨Ç°ª¶¥¥DºÞ¤´ÂÂ-t¾á¸û¬°ÁcÂøªº¤u§@¡A¦¹¤D¦]¨ä¥»¨-¤~¯à¬Û¹ï¦Ó¨¥¨ãµ}¤Ö©Ê¡A¦Ó¤½¥q»Ý-n³o¼Ëªº¤H¤~¡A¬G¨ä¥i¦ÛºÞ²z¤H¤O¥«³õªºÄ³»ù¤¤Àò¨ú·¸¹S¡A±q¦ÓÀò¨ú¸û°ªªºÁ~¹S¡CFinkelstein and Hambrick¡]1989¡^«ü¥X¡A¤½¥qªº½ÆÂøµ{«×¥i¦³³\\¦h¦Ò¶qªº¤è¦¡¡A¦ý³Ì-«-nªº¦Ò¶qÀ³¬°¤½¥q¦h¨¤¤Æµ{«×¡A°ò¥»¤W·í¤½¥q¦h¨¤¤Æµ{«×·U°ª¡A°ª¶¥¥DºÞªº¨Mµ¦Åv--·|·U¤j¡A¨äÁ~¹S«K·U°ª¡F¦¹¥~¡A®Ú¾Ú¬ã¨s«ü¥X¦]Áʨ֦ÓÂX±iªº¨Æ·~³æ¦ì¡A¨ä°ª¶¥¥DºÞªº¦ÛªvÅv--¡A¸û¦]¤½¥q¤º³¡¦¨ªø¦ÓÂX®iªº¨Æ·~³æ¦ì¬°¤j¡A¬G¨ä¬õ§Q¼ú¹S»P¨äÁZ®ÄÃö«Y¸û¬°±K¤Á¡]Urgson & Steer¡A1984¡C¡^
4¡B²£«~®t²§©Ê
Finkelstein & Hambrick¡]1989¡^ªº¬ã¨sµo²{¡A¤½¥q²£«~©ÎªA°È®t²§©Ê«Ü¤j®É¡A¨ä®ÄªG·|»P¤½¥q¦h¨¤¤Æ¬Û¦ü¡F²£«~®t²§©Ê·U°ª¡A°ª¶¥¥DºÞªº¨Mµ¦Åv--«K·U¤j¡A¶i¦Ó¼vÅT¨äÁ~¹S¡C
5¡B¤½¥q-·ÀI
Hill and Phan (1991)ªº¬ã¨s«ü¥X¡A°ª¶¥¥DºÞ±N¨äÁ~¹S»P¤½¥q-·ÀI³sµ²¬O³Ì²Å¦X¨ä§Q¯qªº¡A¦]¬°·í¤½¥qªº-·ÀI·U¤j®É¡AºÞ²zªÌ-±Á{¸gÀ礣µ½¦Ó¥¢¥h¤u§@ªº¾÷²v¤]·U¤j¡A¥Ñ©ó°ª¶¥¥DºÞ¤£®e©ö¦A§ä¨ìÃþ¦üªº¤u§@¡A¥¢·~¹ï¨ä¥¼¨Óªº²{ª÷¬y¶q¦³·¥¬°ÄY-«ªº¼vÅT¡A©Ò¥H¦b-·ÀI¸û°ªªº¤½¥q¤¤¡A°ª¶¥¥DºÞ·|-n¨D¸û°ªÁ~¹S¡A¥H§@¬°¥¼¨Ó¸U¤@¥¢·~®Éªº«O»Ù¡C
¡]¤G¡^»PºÞ²zªÌ¦³Ãöªº¦]¯À
20
1¡B°ª¶¥¥DºÞªº¨Mµ¦Åv--
°ª¶¥¥DºÞªº»ù-Ȧb©ó¨ä¥i¯à¹ï¤½¥q²£¥Í¦h¤Ö°^Äm¦Ó©w¡A¦Ó°^Ämªº¤j¤p°£¤F±ÂºX¥»¨-¯à¤O¼vÅT¥~¡A§ó»P¨ä¨Mµ¦Åv--©Î¥i¯àªº¦æ°Ê½d³ò±K¤Á¬ÛÃö¡C·íÀô¹Ò¸ûÃ-©w®É¡A¥i¦æªº¨Mµ¦¤è®×¿ï¾Ü¸û¤Ö¡A°ª¶¥¥DºÞ¥iµo´§¤§³B¥ç¸û¤Ö¡A¬G¨äÁ~¹S¸û§C¡F·íÀô¹Ò³B©óÅܰʮɡAºÞ²zªÌ-±¹ï¤£½T©w¤§¥¼¨Ó¡A¨ä¨Mµ¦Åv--±N¸û¤j¡A¥i¯àªº¼ç¦b°^Äm¥ç¸û¤j¡A¤½¥q¨Ì¿à¨ä¤~¯àªºµ{«×¤]ÀH¤§¸û¤j¡A¬G¸³¨Æ·|Ä@·N¥I¥X¸û°ªªºÁ~¹S¥h§l¤Þ»P¯d¦íÀu¨qªº°ª¶¥¥DºÞ¡]Finkelstein & Hambrick¡A1989¡C¡^
2¡B°ª¶¥¥DºÞªº¤H¤O¸ê¥»
Becker (1964)ªº¤H¤O¸ê¥»²z½×»¡©ú¡A¤@-Ó¤H©Ò¾Ö¦³ªº¤H¤O¸ê¥»·U¦h¡A«h¨ä¥Í²£¤O·U°ª¡A¬G¨ä©ÒÀò±oªºÁ~¹S¤]·U°ª¡F¦¹³B©Ò«üªº¤H¤O¸ê¥»¬O¤@-Ó¤H¦b±Ð¨|©M¤u§@¸gÅç¤Wªº§ë¸ê©M²Ö¿n¡CMuphy (1985)«ü¥X¥ú¾aÁZ®Ä¤@¶µ¨ÃµLªk§¹¥þ¸ÑÄÀºÞ²zªÌ©ÒÀò±oªºÁ~¹S¡A¨ä¥L½Ñ¦p±Ð¨|¤ô·Ç¡B¤u§@¸gÅç¡B¯à¤Oµ¥¬Ò·|¼vÅT¨ìºÞ²zªÌ©ÒÀò±oªºÁ~¹S¡C 3¡B¦~ÄÖ
Finkelstein & Hambrick (1989)ªº¬ã¨sµo²{¡A°ª¶¥¥DºÞ¦b¦~¸ê¬Û¦Pªº±¡ªp¤U¡A¨äÁ`Á~¹S©M¦~ÄÖ§e²{-ËU«¬Ãö«Y¡C³oªí¥Ü¬Û¦PªºÁ~¹S-pµe¹ï¤£¦P¦~ÄÖªº°ª¶¥¥DºÞ¦³¤£¦Pªº®ÄªG¡C¥t¥~¡AHettenhouse (1971)«ü¥X¤£¦Pªº°ª¶¥¥DºÞ·|¦]¨ä-Ó¤H®t²§¦Ó°¾¦n¤£¦PªºÁ~¹S¨î«×¡C
¡]¤T¡^¥~¬ÉÀô¹Ò¦]¯À
1¡BºÞ²z¤H¤O¥«³õ
°ª¶¥¥DºÞªºÁ~¹S¥i³Q»{¬°¬O¨ä¤~¯à¦b¥«³õ¤ÏÀ³¤Uªºµ²ªG¡A¦¹µ²
21
ªGºÝ¿à¸gÀÙ±¡ªp»P¤H¤Oªº¬Û¹ï¨Ñ»Ý±¡ªp¡A¥Ñ¼ç¦b¤§¶±¥DÄv»ù¦Ó±o¡A¬GºÞ²z¤H¤O¥«³õ¶É¦V¨M©w³Ì§CÁ~¹S¤ô·Ç¡]
Ciscel and Carroll¡A1980¡C¡^
2¡B²£·~¦]¯À
²£·~¦]¯À¦b¨M©w°ª¶¥¥DºÞªºÁ~¹S®É¡A§êºt¤F-«-nªº¨¤¦â¡A¨ä¼vÅTªº¦]¯À¥]¬A¦³¡G²£·~Àò§Q²v¡B²£·~¦¨ªø²v¡B¬ì§Þ¼h¦¸¡]R & D±K¶°«×¡^¥H¤Î¦P·~Á~¹S¤ô·Çµ¥¡C 3¡Bµ|-t
Miller and Scholes (1981)«ü¥X°ª¶¥¥DºÞªº¿EÀy©Ê¤u¨ã¡A¶Ç²Î¤W°¾¦n¨Ï¥ÎªÑ²¼ÁʶR¿ï¾ÜÅv¡A¦Ó«D²{ª÷¬õ§Q¡A¨ä¥D-n¦Ò¼{§Y¬°µ|-t¡C¥Ñ©ó¸ê¥»§Q±o¤§µ|-t¸û©Ò±oµ|¬°§C¡A¬G°ª¶¥¥DºÞ¥ÑªÑ²¼ÁʶR¿ï¾ÜÅv©ÒÀò±oÁ~¹Sªº¹ê»Ú©Ò±o¡A¤j©ó¦PÃB¤§²{ª÷¬õ§Q¡A°ª¶¥¥DºÞ¦ÛµM°¾¦nªÑ²¼ÁʶR¿ï¾ÜÅv¡]¾G¬°«Ö¡A¥Á81¡C¡^
22
²Ä°Ñ³¹ ¬ã¨s¤èªk
¥»¬ã¨s¤§¥D-n¥Øªº¦b±´°Q¹ØÀI¤½¥qªºªÑÅvµ²ºc¡B°ª¶¥¥DºÞÁ~¹S¨î«×»P¸gÀç®Ä²v¶¡¤§¬ÛÃöµ{«×¬°¦ó¡A-ÚÀ˵ø¦s¦b©ó¹ØÀI¤½¥q¤§¥N²z°ÝÃD¡A¬O§_»P¤@¯ë²£·~¦³©Ò¤£¦P¡F¥t¥~¹ï©óµû¦ô¹ØÀI¤½¥qªº¸gÀçÁZ®Ä¦Ó¨¥¡AµL½×¬O¾ÇªÌ¥ç©Î¥Á¶¡ªºµûµ¥¾÷ºc¡]¦p¡A¤¤µØ¼x«H©Ò¡A¤Ñ¤UÂø»xµ¥¡A¡^©Ò±Ä¥Î¤§¿Å¶q«ü¼Ð»Pµû¦ô¤@¯ë¥ø·~µL²§¡A¦ý¹ØÀI·~¥Ñ©ó¨ä¸gÀç¯S®í©Ê¤Î·|-p¤Wªº¿W¯S©Ê¡A¨Ï¥Î©ó¤@¯ë¥ø·~¿Å¶qÁZ®Ä¤§«ü¼Ð¡A¨Ã¤£§¹¥þ¾A¦X®M¥Î¦b¹ØÀI¤½¥qªº¸gÀçÁZ®Ä¿Å¶q¤W¡]¸-¿Aµ×¡A¥Á89¡¡^A¤S¹ØÀI·~ÄÝ©ó¦h¤¸§ë¤J»P²£¥X¤§¦æ·~¡]¼B¯Â¤§¡A¥Á83¡¡^A¬G¥»¤å±N¤£±Ä¥Î¶Ç²Î¤§·|-p©Î°]°È¤ñ²vªk¡F¥»¬ã¨s±N¤À¬°¨â-Ó¶¥¬q¶i¦æ¡F²Ä¤@¶¥¬q±N°ê¤º¹ØÀI¤½¥q¥Á°ê86-88¦~«×¤§¸gÀç®Ä²v¡A¥HµL¥À¼Æ¤§DEA¤ÀªRªk§@¤@¿Å¶q¡F²Ä¤G¶¥¬q¬°¹B¥Î¦h¤¸°jÂk¤ÀªRªk¡A¨Ó½T©w°ê¤º¹ØÀI¤½¥qªÑÅvµ²ºc¹ï©ó¦U¶µ¸gÀç®Ä²v«ü¼Ðªº¼vÅT¡F¥»³¹±NÄÄ-zªñ¦~¨Óªº¦h¦ì¾ÇªÌ¡A©ó¿Å¶qª÷¿ÄÅé¨t¤§¸gÀç®Ä²v®É¡A©Ò¼s¬°±Ä¥Îªº¡u®Ä²v«e½t¥Í²£¨ç¼Æªk¡v¤§²z½×-I´º¡A¥H¤Î¥»¬ã¨s©Ò±Ä¥Î©ó¿Å¶q¹ØÀI·~ªº¦U¶µ§ë¤J²£¥X«ü¼Ð¡F³Ì«á¨Ã»¡©ú¥»¬ã¨s¤§¦U¶µ°²»¡¡C
23
²Ä¤@¸`
¹ØÀI¤½¥q¸gÀç®Ä²vµû¦ô
¦³Ãö¸gÀç®Ä²vµû¦ô¼Ò¦¡¤è-±¡A¹L¥h¾ÇªÌ®õ¥b®Ú¾Ú¸ê®Æ¦ô-pÃä¬É¨ç¼Æ¡]frontier function¡^¡A¦A¨Ì¾ÚÃä¬É¨ç¼Æ±À¦ô¦U¨Mµ¦³æ¦ì¡]decision making unit¡ADMU¡^¤§¦ô-p-È¡A¨Ã¥Ñ¤wª¾¤§Æ[¹î-È»P¦ô-p-ȿŶq¦UDMU¤§®Ä²v¡C¹L¥h¦b³B²zÃä¬É¨ç¼Æ¤j¦h±Ä¨ú³Ì¤j²£¶qªk¡]Aigner & Chu¡A1968¡¡^C¦Ó¥»¤å©Ò±Ä¥Îªº¸ê®Æ¥]µ¸¤ÀªRªk¡]DEA¡¡^A¬O¤@ºØ®Ä²v«e½t¥Í²£¨ç¼Æªk¡F¦b¸gÀپǤW¤D«ü©Ò¦³¥i¯à¬°³Ì¨Î¸Ñ¤§ÂI¡A¥Ñ¦UÂI©Ò²Õ¦¨ªº³s½u—¥]µ¸½u¡A¦Ó¦¹±ø¥]µ¸½uºÙ¬°®Ä²v«e½t¡C¨Ï¥Î¦¹¤ÀªRªkªº-«ÂI¦b©ó³B²z¦hºØ§ë¤J²£¥X¶µ¡A¥HÀ˵ø¦U§ë¤J²£¥X¶µ¹ï©ó¬Û¹ï®Ä²v-Ȫº°^Ämµ{«×¡F¦Ó¦¹ºØ¿Å¶q®Ä²v¤èªk¸û¨ã¦³¤½¥-©Ê»P«ÈÆ[©Ê¡C
¤@¡B Farrell¤§®Ä²v¿Å¶q¼Ò«¬
DEA¼Ò¦¡³Ì¦-¤§·§©À«Y¥ÑFarrell¡]1957¡^´£¥X¡A¤]´N¬O¡u¥Í²£Ãä¬É¡vªº·§©À¡A¦b¸gÀپǤW§Y¥Nªí®Ä²v«e½t©Î¥]µ¸½uªº·N¸q¡A§Y¦b©Ò¦³¥i¯à¸Ñ¤¤©Ò§Î¦¨³Ì¨Î¸Ñ¤§¤@±øÃä¬É¡C¯÷Á|¤@¨Ò¥[¥H»¡©ú¡G-Y¦³¨â§ë¤J¶µX1¡BX2»P³æ¤@²£¥X
Y¡A¨Ã¦³A¡BB¡BC¡BD¡BE¤--ÓDMU¡A¨ä¼Æ
-Ȧpªí3.1©Ò¥Ü¡C«h¤Z¦ì©ó¥Í²£Ãä¬É¤WªºDMU¡A¦pC¡BD¡BE¡A¨ä¬Û¹ï®Ä²v¬°¤@¡A§Y³Qµø¬°¦³®Äªº³æ¦ì¡F¦Ó¤£¦b¥Í²£Ãä¬É¤WªºDMU¡A¦pA¡BB¡A¨ä®Ä²v³æ¦ì¬Ò¤p©ó1¡C
24
ªí
3.1 ¤-¨Mµ¦³æ¦ì¤§§ë¤J²£¥X¤§°²³]©Ê¸ê®Æ
®Ú¾Ú¹Ï3.1©Ò¥Ü¡A¦Ó¦¹®É¬Û¹ïµL®Ä²vªºA»PB¨â³æ¦ìªº®Ä²v-È-pºâ¡A§Y©w¸q¬°¨Mµ¦³æ¦ì¨ì-ìÂI¤§¶ZÂ÷»P®Ä²v«e½t¨ì-ìÂI¤§¶ZÂ÷ªº¤ñ-È¡FDMU-Aªº¬Û¹ï®Ä²v¬°OA/OA¡ADMU-B«h¬°OB/OB¡C
¹Ï 3.1 ¥H¥Í²£¬É½u¿Å¶q¬Û¹ï®Ä²v
§ë ¤J
X2
18 6 4 6 28
²£¥X Y 6 3 4 3 7
§ë ¤J «Y ¼Æ X1/Y
2 3 4 2 1
X2/Y
3 2 1 2 4
DMU X1
12 A
9 B
12 C
6 D
7 E
’’
X2/Y
A’ E A B D C B’ X1/Y
O
25
Farrell©ó©T©w³W¼Ò³ø¹S¤§°²³]¤U¡A±N¥Í²£®Ä²v¤À¬°°t¸m®Ä²v»P§Þ³N®Ä²v¡C°²³]¤@¼t°Ó¨Ï¥Î¨âºØ¡]X1¡AX2¡^ªº§ë¤J¡]¹ÏQQ’¬°µ¥²£¶q¦±½u¡A¥Nªí¥Í²£¤@³æ¦ì
¦X¡A«h¥Í²£²Õ¦X¥²¸¨¦b
3.2¡¡^A²£¶q¬°Y¡C
Y©Ò»Ý¡]X1¡AX2¡^¤§³Ì¤p¥i¯à²Õ
QQ’¥k¤W¤è¡Aªí¥Ü¨ä¤£¨ã¦³§¹¥þ§Þ³N®Ä²v¡A¦]
OP/OTªº¡]X1¡AX2¡^«K¥i¥H
Farrell
¬°-Y¸Ó¼t°Ó¨ã¦³§¹¥þ§Þ³N®Ä²v¡A¥u»Ý¥Î
¥Í²£¡C¥ç§Y¥H¸û¤Öªº§ë¤J¡A«K¥i¥Hºû«ù¬Û¦Pªº²£¥X¤ô·Ç¡C¦]¦¹¡A
¥HOP/OT¨Ó¿Å¶q¸ÓTÂIªº§Þ³N¶i¨B®Ä²v¡C·íOP/OT=1®É¡Aªí¥Ü¸Ó¼t°Ó¬°¨ã¦³§¹¥þ§Þ³N®Ä²vªº¼t°Ó¡A¥ç§Y¸Ó¼t°ÓªºÆ[¹î-È·|¸¨©ó¦³®Ä²vªº³æ¦ìµ¥²£¶q¦±½u¡C·íOP/OT<1®É¡Aªí¥Ü¸Ó¼t°Ó¤£¨ã§¹¥þ§Þ³N®Ä²v¡A¦¹®ÉÆ[¹î-ȱN·|¸¨©ó¦±½uQQ’ªº¥k¤W¤è¡C
AA’¤§±×²v¡A¥i©w¸q
°²³]¼t°Ó©Ò-±Á{¤§¦]¯À¥«³õ¬°§¹¥þÄvª§¥«³õ¡C°²³]§ë¤JX1¡AX2
¤§¬Û¹ï»ù®æ¤ñ¬°
TÂI¤§°t¸m®Ä²v¬°OR/OT¡A¨Ã©w
¸qÁ`®Ä²v¬°OP/OT¡A¥Ñ¦¹±oª¾Á`®Ä²v¬°§Þ³N®Ä²v»P°t¸m®Ä²v¤§-¼¿n¡A¦p¤Uªº¼Æ¾Ç¦¡¡G
OE=TE¡ÑPE
OP/OT=OR/OT¡ÑOP/OR
¹Ï3.2 Farrell ®Ä²v¤§¿Å¶q
X2 Q T A
R P
E Q’
O A’ X1
26
¤G¡B
CCR Model
Charnes¡BCooper and Rhodes (1978)§Q¥ÎFarrell¤§Æ[ÂI¡A´£¥X¤@¤À¼Æ½u©Ê³W¹º¡]fractional linear programming ¡^¼Ò«¬¡A¥Î¥H¿Å¶q²Õ´¤§¬Û¹ï®Ä²v¡C¦UDMU¥i¥ô¿ï½u©Ê²Õ¦X«Y¼Æ¥Hªí¥Ü¹ï¦¹¦]¤l¤§-«µø±¡§Î¡A¦ý¦b¥ô¿ïªº¹Lµ{¤¤¡A¥²¶·º¡¨¬¤@--¨î±ø¥ó¡A§Y¥ô¿ïªº«Y¼Æ¥Î©ó¨ä¥LDMU®É¡A©Òµû¦ôªº®Ä²v-Ȥ£±o¶W¹L1.0¡A¦b¦¹±ø¥ó--¨î¤§¤U¨üµû¦ôªºDMU¥i¥ô¿ï²Õ¦X«Y¼Æ©Òµû¦ôªº®Ä²v-ȹF¨ì³Ì¤j¡C°²³]DMU¦@¦³n-Ó¡A¦UDMUj ¡]j¡×1¡A……..¡An¡^«Y¨Ï¥ÎmºØ§ë¤J¡AXj¡×¡]X1j¡A…….¡AXmj¡^¡Ö0¡A¥Í²£SºØ²£¥X¡AYj¡×
²v¥i¥Ñ¦p¤U¤§¼Ò¦¡¨D±o¡G
¡]
Y1…………Ysj.¡¡A«h¥ô¤@^DMUjo¤§®Ä
Max hjo=
∑uryrjo
r=1m
s
∑vixijo
i=1
S.t r=1
m
∑uryrj
s
≤1 ……………....3.1
∑vixij
i=1
ur≥0 for r=1,2…….,S ¡Fj=1……,n
vi≥0 for i=1,2…….,m £`¡Ö0
27
¨ä¤¤ xij¡G¥Nªí²Ä
yij¡G¥Nªí²Äur¡G¥Nªí²Ävr¡G¥Nªí²Ä
j-ÓDMU¤§²ÄI¶µ§ë¤J-È j-ÓDMU¤§²Är¶µ²£¥X-È r-Ó²£¥X¶µ¤§µêÀÀÅv¼Æ i-Ó§ë¤J¶µ¤§µêÀÀÅv¼Æ
£`¡G¥Nªí«Dªü°ò¦Ì¼w¼Æ¡]non-Archimedean quantity¡^ hjo¡G¥Nªí¤§¬Û¹ï®Ä²v-È
DEA¼Ò¦¡¤¤ªºDMU§ë¤J¶µ¡A²£¥X¶µ¥i¥H¤U¦C¼Ò¦¡ªí¥Ü¤§¡G §ë¤J¶µ¡G DMU1 DMU2………………..DMUn
V1 X11 X12 X1n
V2 X21 X22 X2n
. . . . . . . . Vm Xm1 Xm2 Xmn
28
²£¥X¶µ¡G
U1 Y11 Y12…………………Y1n
U2 Y21 Y22……………….. Y2n . . . . . . . . . . . . Us Ys1 Ys2……………..…. Ysn
¡]3.1¡^¦¡ªº¤À¼Æ³W«h¦b¹ê»Ú¨D¸Ñ¤W¤§¤£©ö¡ACharnes ¡ACooper (1962)¥i¤©¼Ð·Ç¤Æ¬°¤@½u©Ê¼Ò¦¡¥H¤è«K¨D¸Ñ¡AÂà´««áªºÅܼƥHur,viªí
¥Ü¡A¨Ã¤À¬°§ë¤J¾É¦V¼Ò¦¡©M²£¥X¾É¦V¼Ò¦¡¤§¤GºØ¤è¦¡¨D¸Ñ¡F¥B¥Ñ©ó
3.1¼Ò¦¡ªº¥Ø¼Ð¨ç¼Æ¬°¤À¼Æ§Î¦¡¡A¤£©ö-pºâ¡A¥B¦³µL½a¦h¸Ñ¤§ºÃ¼{¡A¥iÂà´«¬°3.2¼Ò¦¡¥H§Q°õ¦æ¡C
s
Max hjo=
∑uryrjo………………..3.2
r=1n
∑uryrj−∑vixij≤0
j=1
j=1
n
for i=1,…………,m ¡Fr=1,……..,s¡Fj=1,…..,n
29
ur¡Avi ≥ε¡Ö0
¦p±N
3.2¼Ò¦¡§Q¥Î¹ï°¸¼Ò¦¡3.3¹Bºâ±N§ó¬°¤è«K¡A¨Ã¥iÀò±o§ó¦h
ªº¸ê°T¡C
S.t
−+
λj,sijo,srjo
+
λy−s∑jrjrjo=yro j=1n
−
∑λjxij−θxijo+sijo=0…………3.3
j=1n
≥0
i=1,……….,m r=1,………,s j=1,…..,n
¨ä¤¤ £c¡G¥Nªí¸ÓDMUªº©Ò¦³§ë¤Jµ¥¤ñ¨ÒÁY´îªº¼ç¦bÃB«× Sijo¡G¥Nªí§ë¤J¶µªº®tÃBÅܼơ]Slack varible¡^ Srjo: ¥Nªí²£¥X¶µªº®tÃBÅܼơ]Slack varible¡^
¨Mµ¦³æ¦ì©Ò¨D±o¤§¥Ø¼Ð-È-Y¬°1¥B¨ä®tÃBÅܼƬ°0¡A«hºÙ¬°¬Û¹ï¦³®Ä²v¡F-Y®Ä²v-Ȥp©ó1¡A«h¡]£cXijo¡Ð
−+
Sijo¡AYrjo+Srjo¡^¥i§@¬°¸Ó¨M
+−
µ¦³æ¦ì§ï¶i®Ä²v¤§°Ñ¦Ò¡C
30
¤T¡B
BCC ¼Ò«¬
Banker¡BCharnes and Cooper (1984)´£¥XBCC¼Ò«¬¡A¦¹¼Ò«¬¥ÑFarrell¤ÎCCR¼Ò«¬·§©Àªº-×¥¿¤Î©µ¦ù¡A¨ä»PCCR¼Ò«¬³Ì¥D-nªº®t§O¬O¦b©óBCC¼Ò«¬¥i¥H±´°QDMU¦b¡uÅܰʳW¼Ò³ø¹S¡v¤§°²³]¤Uªº±¡ªp¡CCCR¼Ò«¬¥D-n¬O¦b°Q½×¡u©T©w³W¼Ò³ø¹S¡v¤§¤Uªº±¡ªp¡A¦ÓBCC¼Ò«¬¥i¥H¥Î¨Ó-pºâ-Ó§Oªº¯Âºé§Þ³N®Ä²v¡]Banker,1984¡C¡^
°²³]¥H¤@¶µ§ë¤J¡]X¡^»P¤@¶µ²£¥X¡]Y¡^ªº±¡§Î¥[¥H»¡©ú¡]¹Ï3.3¡A¡^¹ï©ó¨Mµ¦³æ¦ìC¦Ó¨¥¡A©T©wªºOF²£¥X»Ý-nFAªº§ë¤J¡A¦ýB¥u»Ý-nFBªº§ë¤J¦]¦¹¥HFA/FB¨Ó¿Å¶qC¤§¯Âºé§Þ³N®Ä²v¡A¦P²z¡AG«o¯à°÷¥H³Ì¤j¥-§¡²£¶q¤§³W¼Ò¨Ó¥Í²£¡A¦]¦¹¥HFG/FB¨Ó¿Å¶qC¤§³W¼Ò®Ä²v¡CDÂI»PMÂI¦]¬Ò¦ì©ó»P-ìÂI¤§³s½u¤W¡A¥Nªí¦¹¨âÂI¤§¨C³æ¦ì§ë¤J²£¥X©Ò¹ïÀ³ªº¤ñ¨Ò¬O¬Û¦Pªº¡C¦¹ºØ¨Ï§ë¤J²£¥X½u¥²¶·¬°³q¹L-ìÂI¤§ª½½uªº²{¶H«Y¥H¡u©T©w³W¼Ò³ø¹S¡v¬°°²³]±ø¥ó¤§¯S¦â¡C¦ÓABDE½u«h¬°¡uÅܰʳW¼Ò³ø¹S¡v¤§°²³]¤Uªº®Ä²v«e½t¥]µ¸½u¡C
¹Ï3.3 BCC¼Ò«¬¤§DEA
Y M
E
D F G B C O A X
31
²Ä¤G¸`
¸ê®Æ³B²z
¨Ï¥Î¡u¸ê®Æ¥]µ¸¤ÀªRªk¡v¿Å¶q¹ØÀI¤½¥q¤§¸gÀç®Ä²v®É¡A¦p¦ó¿ï¨ú¾A¦Xªº§ë¤J»P²£¥X«ü¼Ð¡A±N·|¼vÅT¦¹µû¦ôµ²ªGªº¥¿½T»P§_¡A¬°¨Ï¥Î¦¹¤èªk³Ì¬°-«-nªº¨BÆJ¡A¤×¨ä¥H¹ØÀI²£·~¥»¨-¨ã¦³¤§¯S©Ê-~²§©ó»s³y·~¡A¥]¬A¤FµL§Î©Ê¡B³Ò¤O±K¶°©Ê¡B¤£¥i¤À³Î©Ê¡BÅܲ§©Ê¡B©ö®ø¥¢©Êµ¥ªA°È·~¤§¯S©Ê¡]§d°êµØ¡A¥Á86¡¡^F¦ÓÀôÅU°ê¤º¥~¾ÇªÌ¹ï©ó§ë¤J²£¥X«ü¼Ð¤§¿ï¨ú¤W¡A¦U¤è·N¨£¤Àª[¨ÃµL¤@-P¤§¬Ýªk¡F¥»¸`±N±´°Q¦U«ü¼Ð¤§¥Nªí·N²[¥H¤Î¾A¦X»P§_¡A¨Ã´£¥X¥»¬ã¨s¤§¿ï¨úÅܼơC
¤@¡B §ë¤J¶µ¤§¿ï¨ú
¶Ç²Î¸gÀپǤj³£±N°Ñ»P¥Í²£ªº¤H¤O¥H¤Î¸ê¥»³]³Æµø¬°§ë¤J¦]¯À¡A¨ä¥D-nªº¥Øªº«Y¦bÆ[¹î¤H¤O»P¸ê¥»³]³Æ¨âºØ§ë¤J¦]¯À¡A¦b¥Í²£¹Lµ{¤¤©Ò²£¥Íªº´À¥N®ÄªG¡C³oºØ¬É©w§ë¤Jªº¤è¦¡¡A¥D-n¤D°w¹ï»s³y·~¤§¥Í²£¡C¦ý¹ï©ó¹ØÀI·~¦Ó¨¥¡A¥Ñ©ó¸ê¥»µ²ºc»P¤@¯ë²£·~¦³¬Æ¤j¤§®t²§¡A¨ä-«ÂI¦b©ó-t¶Å»·°ª©ó¸ê¥»¡A¬°¤@-t¶Å¸gÀ礧¼Ò¦¡¡A¦]¦¹¸ê¥»³]³Æ¹ï²£¥Xªº°^Äm´N¤£¤Î»s³y·~¨Ó±o-«-n¤F¡C¦]¬°¹ØÀI·~©Ò¥Í²£ªº²£«~ÄÝ©ó¤@ºØµL§Îªº°Ó«~¡A¥ç§Y·í©Ó«O¨Æ¬Gµo¥Í¤§®É¡A¹ï³Q«OÀI¤H©Î¨ü¯q¤H¼i¦æ¸ÉÀv³d¥ôªº¤@ºØ©Ó¿Õ¡C³o¶µ²£«~¬O§_¦s¦b¨Ã«D¹ØÀI·~ªÌ¦L»s«O³æ«K¨¬¥H¦¨¥ß¡A¥²¶·¥õ¿à¤j¶q¤§¥~¶Ô¤H-û©ÛÅó¡A¶i¦Ó»P-n«O¤Hñ-q«OÀI«´¬ù¡A³o¶µ¹ØÀI²£«~ªº¥Í²£¤è§i§¹¦¨¡]§õ§g«Ì¡A¥Á83¡¡^C·íµM³o¨ÇµL§Î²£«~¦b¥Í²£ªº¹Lµ{¤¤¡A°£¤F»Ý-n¥~¶Ô¤H-ûªº©ÛÅ󤧥~¡A¤´»Ý¸g¥Ñºëºâ³¡ªù¥H¤Î¨ä¥L³¡ªù¤º¶Ô¤H-û¨}¦nªº°t¦X¤~¯à¶¶§Q§¹¦¨¡C©Ò¥H¹ï¹ØÀI·~ªÌ¦Ó¨¥¡A¥~¶Ô»P¤º¶Ô¤H-û®É¬°¨â¶µ-«-nªº§ë¤J¦]¯À¡C
°£¤F¥~¶Ô»P¤º¶Ô¤H-û¨âºØ¤H¤O§ë¤Jªº¦]¯À¥H¥~¡A¨ä¥L-«-n§ë¤J¦]¯À¦p·~°È-ûªº¦þª÷¤ä¥X³¡¤À¡A¬O¤@¬Û·í¥iÆ[ªºÀç·~¶O¥Î¡F¦AªÌ¦p¹q¸£
32
³]³Æ¤§¨Ï¥Î¡A·|-p®v¡B«ß®vµ¥©Ò´£¨Ñªº±M·~ªA°È¡A¥H¤Î¿ì¤½ÆUªÙ¯²ª÷¶O¥Î¹ï©ó¹ØÀI·~ªÌªº¸gÀç¤]¦s¦³¤@©wµ{«×ªº¼vÅT¡]§õ§g«Ì¡A¥Á
83¡C¡^
¦ý¬O¹ØÀI¦~³ø¤¤¨ÃµL¤W-z¶O¥Î¤§¸Ô²Ó¸ê®Æ¡A¥u¥H¡u·~°ÈºÞ²z¶O¥Î¡v¤@-Ó¬ì¥Ø¨Óªí¥Ü¡A¦bµLªkÀò±o¦U¶µ¸Ô²Ó¶O¥Î¸ê®Æªº±¡ªp¤U¡A¥»¬ã¨s±N¥H¦U·~ªÌ¦¹¶µ¡u·~°ÈºÞ²z¶O¥Î¡v°µ¬°§ë¤JÅܼƤ§¤@¡C
¸g¥Ñ¤W-z¤§»¡©ú¡A¥»¬ã¨s±N¥H¤T¶µ¦]¯À°µ¬°§ë¤JÅܼơG ¡]¤@¡^ ¤º¶Ô¤H-û¼Æ ¡]¤G¡^ ¥~¶Ô¤H-û¼Æ ¡]¤T¡^ ·~°ÈºÞ²z¶O¥Î
¤G¡B ²£¥X¶µ¤§¿ï¨ú
²£¥X¶µ¤§«ü¼Ð¿ï¨ú¤W¬°°ê¤º¥~¾ÇªÌ·N¨£¬Û·í¤Àª[¤§³B¡CHouston and Simon (1970)¥H¡uÁ`«O¶O¦¬¤J¡v°µ¬°¹ØÀI¤½¥q²£¥Xªº´À¥N-È¡A¥H°jÂk¤ÀªRªº¤èªk¡AÀË©w¹ØÀI·~ªÌ³W¼Ò¸gÀÙªº°ÝÃD¡AH&S§Q¥Î¾îÂ_-±ªº¸ê®Æ¨ÓÁקK«OÀI¶O²vÅܰʹï©ó²£¥X¿Å¶q®É©Ò³y¦¨ªº¼vÅT¡A¨Ã¥B»{¬°·~ªÌ¤§¶¡ªº¦UºØ²£«~¨ã¦³¦P½è©Ê¡A¦ý¥Ñ©ó¦U·~ªÌ¤§¶¡¦UºØ²£«~ªº²Õ¦X¤ñ¨Ò¤£¦P¡A-Y¥H¦U·~ªÌªºÁ`«O¶O¦¬¤J°µ¬°¨ä²£¥X´À¥N-È¡A±N³y¦¨¬YºØµ{«×ªº°¾»~¡A¦]¦¹¥L-̱N¦UÀIºØ«O¶O¦¬¤J¦ûÁ`«O¶O¦¬¤Jªº¤ñ¨Ò¯Ç¤J¦^Âk¼Ò«¬¤¤¡A¥HÁקK¸Ó¦]¤l©Ò¥i¯à³y¦¨ªº°¾»~¡C
¨Ï¥Î¡u«O¶O¦¬¤J¡v°µ¬°²£¥X¶µ¤§¬ã¨s¡A°ê¥~¤è-±¦³¡GBlair¡BJackson and Vogal (1975)¡BPraetz (1980)¡BGrace and Timme (1990)¥H¤ÎFecher (1993)µ¥¾ÇªÌ¡F°ê¤º¤è-±¦³¡G±i»·»«¡]¥Á77¡¡^B¼B¯Â¤§¡]¥Á83¡¡^B§õ§g«Ì¡]¥Á83¡¡^B¾G¨q®S¡]¥Á85¡^¥H¤Î§d°êµØ¡]¥Á86¡^¡F¥H¤W¾ÇªÌ§¡¥H¡u«O¶O¦¬¤J¡v°µ¬°²£¥X¤§¥N²zÅܼơC
¦ý¬OGeehan (1977)¹ï©ó©M±q¹ØÀI·~ªÌ¶¡²£«~¨ã¦³¦P½è©Êªº°²³]
33
¤§¤U¶i¦Ó»{¬°¥i¥H¥Î«O¶O¦¬¤J§@¬°¿Å¶q¦U¹ØÀI·~ªÌ²£¥Xªº°ò¦´£¥X½èºÃ¡C¥L«ü¥X®Ú¾Ú¬ã¨sÅã¥Ü¡A¬ü°ê¹ØÀI·~ªÌ¤§¶¡¨ä²£«~»ù®æ»P·~ªÌ³W¼Ò¤j¤p¨ã¦³-t¬ÛÃö©Ê¡C¦]¦¹¡A
Geehan»{¬°-Y¥H«O¶O¦¬¤J¨Ó¿Å¶q¹ØÀI
·~ªÌ¤§²£¥X¡A¶Õ¥²³y¦¨¬YºØµ{«×ªº°¾»~¡C
Cummins and Weiss (1998)»{¬°¥H¡u«O¶O¦¬¤J¡v·í¦¨²£¥XÅܼÆÄÝ©ó¦-´Á¾ÇªÌ©Ò±Ä¥Î¡A¦Óªñ¦~¨Óªº¾ÇªÌ¤w-×¥¿¤F³oºØ¿ù»~ªºÆ[©À¡A§ï¥H¡u²z½ß¤ä¥X¡]¡vincurred benefits¡^¤Î¡u·Ç³Æª÷ªº¼W¥[ÃB¡]¡vadditions to reserves¡^³o¨â¶µ¬°¹ØÀI·~²£¥XªºÅܼơA±Ä¥ÎªÌ¦p¡GYuengert (1993)¡BCummins¡BTennyson and Weiss (1998)µ¥¤H¡C
°w¹ï¤W-z¾ÇªÌ©ó¿Å¶q²£¥XÅܼƤ§¤£¤@-P±¡§Î¡A¨s«Y¦óªÌ¬°¨Î¡H¤S¬O§_¦s¦³¥¢·í¤§³B¡HBentson (1982)°w¹ïª÷¿ÄªA°È·~²£¥X¿Å¶q¤èªk¤¤©Ò´£¨ì¡A»{¬°¥u-n²£¥Xªº¿Å¶q¤èªk¯à»P¬ã¨s¥Øªº¤@-P§Y¥i¡C§õ§g«Ì¡]¥Á83¡^«h´£¥X¥HÁ`Åé¸gÀÙ-±¤Î-ÓÅé¼t°Ó-±ªºÆ[ÂI¡A¨Ó¸ÑŪ¾ÇªÌ¶¡©Ò±Ä¥Î¤£¦PÅܼƤ§¬ã¨s¥»·N¡C
¦ý¬O¥»¬ã¨s»{¬°¦p¦ó§ä¨ì¾A¦X«OÀI·~¤§²£¥XÅܼơA°ß¦³¦^Âk¨ì«OÀI·~¤§¥»½è¤Î¨ä¥\\¯à¨s«Y¬°¦ó¡H¤è¯à¥[¥H©w½×¡C¤@¯ë¦Ó¨¥¡A«OÀI¤½¥q°ò¥»¤W´£¨Ñ¤F¤T¶µªA°È¡]Cummins and Weiss¡A1998¡F¡^
¡]¤@¡^ -·ÀIªº¶°¦X¡B©Ó¾á»P¤À´²¡]risk-pooling and risk-bearing¡^ ¡]¤G¡^ ³Q«OÀI¤H©ó·l¥¢µo¥Í«á¤§¡u¹ê½è¤W¡vªº°]°È¸ÉÀv¡]real
financial services relating to insured losses¡^
¡]¤T¡^ ª÷¿Ä¥ò¤¶¡]intermediation¡^
¦]¦¹¡A«OÀI¤½¥q¤§¥\\¯à¦b©ó´£¨Ñ©Ò¦³ªº§ë«O¤j²³¦³§Îªº¡]°]°È¤W¡^¤ÎµL§Îªº¡]¤ß²z¦w¥þ¡^¤§ª÷¿ÄªA°È¡C¦Ó¦óªÌ¤~¯à¾A¤Áªº¥Nªí¦¹¶µªA°È¤§²£¥X¶µ©O¡H¥H¡u«O¶O¦¬¤J¡v¶µ¥Ø¨Ó¬Ý¡A«O¶O©Ò¥Nªíªº²[¸q¤w¸g¬O¡u»ù®æ-¼¤W²£¥X¶q¡¡vA¦Ó«D³æ¿Wªº¡u²£¥X¡]Y¡vuengert¡A1993¡¡^F¦AªÌ¡A±q«O¶Oªº²Õ¦¨¨Ó¬Ý¡A¨ä¹ê¥]§t¤F¨â³¡¤À§Y¯Â«O¶O¡]net premium¡^¤Îªþ¥[«O¶O¡]loading¡¡^Aªþ¥[«O¶O¤º¥]§t¤F·~°È¦þª÷¤Î¦U¶µµo³æ¦¨¥»¡A¦¹³¡¥÷
34
À³ÄÝ©ó¡u§ë¤J¡v¶µ¥Ø¤èÄݦX²z¡F¦³Å³©ó¦¹¥»¬ã¨s»{¬°¥H¡u«O¶O¦¬¤J¡v§@¬°²£¥XÅܼƨ䣫ê·í¡C
¥H¤W-z«OÀI·~¤§¤T¶µ°ò¥»¥\\¯à¨Ó¤ÀªR¡u²z½ß¤ä¥X¡v¤Î¡u·Ç³Æª÷¼W¥[ÃB¡v¦¹¤G¶µ¥N²zÅܼơA¥i¥Hµo²{©Ò¿×ªº¡u²z½ßµ¹¥I¡v¨ä¹ê¥¿¥Nªí¤F«OÀI¤½¥q©Ò¨ã¦³ªº¡u-·ÀI¤§¶°¦X¡B©Ó¾á»P¦X²z¤À°t¡v¤§¥\\¯à¡F¡u·Ç³Æª÷¤§¼W¥[ÃB¡v°£¤F¨Ó¦Û©ó«O¤á©Òú¥æ¤§«O¶O¥~¡A¥ç¤ÏÀ³¤F«OÀI¤½¥qµ½¥[¹B¥Î¦¹¸êª÷¤§¯à¤O¡A¦Ó¤]¥Nªí¤F«OÀI·~ªÌ¬°¡u¸êª÷¥ò¤¶¡v¤§ªA°È¥\\¯à¡C¦]¦¹ªñ¦~¨Ó¤w¦³¦h¦ì¾ÇªÌ±N¦¹¤G¶µµø¬°«OÀI·~¤§²£¥Xªº¥N²zÅܼơA¦p¡GCummins and Zi (1998)¡BCummins¡BTennyson and Weiss (1998)¡BMeador ¡BRyan and Schellorn (1997)¥H¤ÎKim and Grace (1995)µ¥¤H¡C(Cummins and Weiss, 1998)
ºî¦X¤W-z¤ÀªR¡A¥»¬ã¨s±N¥H¹ØÀI¤½·|¦~³ø©Ò´¦ÅS¤§¡u²z½ßª÷µ¹¥I¡v¤Î¡u³d¥ô·Ç³Æª÷¼W¥[ÃB¡v°µ¬°¦U®a·~ªÌ¤§²£¥X¶µ¥Ø¡C
35
²Ä¤T¸`
¬ã¨s°²»¡»P¹êµý¼Ò«¬
¬°¤F±´°QªÑÅvµ²ºc¡B°ª¶¥¥DºÞÁ~¹S»P¹ØÀI¤½¥q¸gÀç®Ä²v¤§Ãö«Y¡A¥»¬ã¨s®Ú¾Ú²z½×»P¤åÄm´£¥X¦U¶µ°²»¡¡A¨Ã¥H¦h¤¸°jÂk¤ÀªRªº¬ã¨s¤èªk¡AÀËÅç¸gÀç®Ä²v»P¬ÛÃöÅܼƤ§¶¡ªº¬ÛÃöµ{«×¦p¦ó¡C
¤@¡B¬ã¨s°²»¡
¨Ì¾ÚKesner (1987)ªº¬ã¨s«ü¥X¡A¸³ºÊ¨Æªº«ùªÑ¤ñ²v·U°ª¡A¨ä-Ó¤H©Ò-±Á{¤§°]°È-·ÀI¡A»P¤½¥q©Ò-±Á{ªÌÃö«Y±K¤Á¡A¥H-P©ó·|¦³§ó¤j°Ê¾÷°õ¦æ¸³ºÊ¨Æ·|ªºÂ¾³d¡AºÊ·þºÞ²z·í§½¡A¦]¦¹¥ø·~ªº¸gÀç®Ä²v·|¸û¦n¡C¥»¬ã¨s¦]¦¹´£¥X¬ã¨s°²»¡¤@¡G
°²»¡¤@¡G
Coughlan and Schmidt (1985)«ü¥X¡A¥Ñ©ó¸ê¥»¥«³õªºÄvª§¡A¤½¥qªº¦sÄò¦³¿à©ó«Øºc¤@¯à¨Ï°ª¶¥¥DºÞ¥HªÑªF§Q¯q¬°¨ÌÂkªº³ø¹S¨î«×¡F§_«h¤½¥q±N-±Á{µLªk»P¨º¨Ç°ª¶¥¥DºÞ½T¹ê¥HªÑªF§Q¯q¬°¨ÌÂkªº¤½¥q¬ÛÄvª§¡CÁ~¸ê¤ô·Ç°ª§Cª½±µ¼vÅT¨ì°ª¶¥¥DºÞªº¦¬¤J¡A»P¥ø·~Àç¹B¦¨¥»¡F¦ýÁ~¸ê¥»¨-¤S¬O¤u§@ªº»¤¦]¡A¤½¥q-Y¯àµ¹¤©°ª¶¥¥DºÞ¸û°ªªº³ø¹S¤ô·Ç¡A«h¨ã¦³¿EÀy§@¥Î©M·N¸q¡A¥i¨Ï°ª¶¥¥DºÞ§ó¦³·NÄ@¥þ¤O¥I¥X¡A¥H´£°ª¤½¥qÁZ®Ä¡C¦Ó¥»¬ã¨s©Ò±´°Q¤§¡u°ª¶¥¥DºÞÁ~¹S¡v¡A±N¥H¡uÁ`¸g²z¡v¤§Á~
¸³ºÊ¨Æ«ùªÑ¤ñ²v¶V°ª¡A«OÀI¤½¥q¸gÀç®Ä²v¶V¦n¡C
36
¹Sµ¹¥I¬°¥Nªí¡F¦]¦¹´£¥X¥»¶µ¬ã¨s¤§°²»¡¤G¡G
°²»¡¤G ¡G
Á`¸g²z¤§Á~¹S¤ô·Ç·U°ª¡A«OÀI¤½¥q¤§¸gÀç®Ä²v·U¦n¡C
¥t¥~¥»¬ã¨s©Ò-n±´°Qªº¥t¤@ijÃD¡A¬°¡uªÑÅv¶°¤¤«×¡v¹ï©ó¤½¥q¸gÀç®Ä²vªº¼vÅTµ{«×¬°¦ó¡C®Ú¾Ú¹L¥h°ê¤º¥~¤§¾ÇªÌ©Ò°µ¹Lªº¬ÛÃö¬ã¨s¡A¨ä¬ã¨sµ²ªG¤Î¬Ýªk¬Û·í¤£¤@-P¡A¤j-P¥iÂk¯Ç¬°¤TºØ¾Ç»¡¡G§Q¯q¦¬ÀÄ°²»¡¡B¾d©T©Ê°²»¡¥H¤ÎªÑÅvµ²ºc©M¸gÀçÁZ®Ä¨ÃµLÃö«Y¡C
¦]¦¹ªÑÅvµ²ºc¹ï©ó¥ø·~¸gÀçÁZ®Äªº¼vÅT¡A¾ÇªÌ¶¡´¶¹M¦s¦b¤£¦Pªº¨£¸Ñ¡F¥»¬ã¨s©Ò-n³]©wªº²Ä¤T¶µÅܼƬ°¡uªÑÅv¶°¤¤«×¡v¡A§Æ±æÂǥѹêÃÒ¬ã¨sªº²Ö¿n¡A¯à¹ï©ó¦¹¤@ijÃD¦³§ó¬°©ú½Tªº©w½×¡C
¤G¡B ¹êÃÒ¼Ò«¬
¬°ÀËÅ祻¤å¤§¬ã¨s°²³]¡A¤D«Ø¥ß¥H¤U¤§°jÂk¼Ò«¬¶i¦æ¬ã¨s¤ÀªR¡F¼Ò«¬¤¤¤§¨ÌÅܼơ]Y¡^¬°¹ØÀI¤½¥q¤§¸gÀç®Ä²v¡A¸ÑÄÀÅܼơ]X¡^¥]§t¼Æ¶µ¥Nªí¥N²z°ÝÃD¤§ªÑÅvÅܼơA¥]¬A¡GªÑÅv¶°¤¤«×¡]SV¡¡^B¸³ºÊ¨Æ«ùªÑ¤ñ²v¡]CHS¡^¥H¤ÎÁ`¸g²zÁ~¹S¡]COM¡C¡^
Y= a+b1¡]CHS¡^+b2¡]COM¡^+b3¡]SV¡^
37
²Ä¸v³¹ ¹êÃÒµ²ªG»P¤ÀªR
¬°¤FÅçÃÒ¥»¤å©Ò´£¥X¤§¬ã¨s°²»¡¬O§_¦¨¥ß¡A¥H¤ÎÅܼƤ§¶¡ªº¬ÛÃö©Ê¡A¥»¬ã¨s¥H«e-±³¹¸`©Ò-z¤§¤G¶¥¬q¬ã¨s¨BÆJ¶i¦æ¹êµý¤ÀªR¡F¦Ó¦U¶µ¤ÀªR©Ò±Ä¥Î¤§¼Ë¥»¸ê®Æ¤Î²Î-p¼Æ¾Ú¡A¥H¤Î¹êÃÒµ²ªG¡A§¡·J¾ã»¡©ú©ó¥H¤U¦U¸`¡C
²Ä¤@¶¥¬q¹êµý¤ÀªR¤§-«ÂI¬°¡A¥H°ê¤º12®a¹ØÀI·~ªÌ©ó¥Á°ê86-88¦~«×¤§¦U¶µ§ë¤J²£¥X«ü¼Ð¡A¥HDEA¤ÀªRªk¨Ó¿Å¶q¦U®a¤§§Þ³N®Ä²v¡]TE¡¡^B¯Âºé§Þ³N®Ä²v¡]PTE¡^¥H¤Î³W¼Ò®Ä²v¡]AE¡C¡^
²Ä¤G¶¥¬q¬°°jÂk¼Ò«¬¤ÀªR¡A±N²Ä¤@¶¥¬q¤§¤TºØ®Ä²v«ü¼Ð§@¬°¦]Åܼơ]Y¡¡^A¦Ó¥H¸³ºÊ¨Æ«ùªÑ¤ñ²v¡]CHS¡¡^BÁ`¸g²zÁ~¹Sµ¹¥I¡]COM¡^¥H¤ÎªÑÅv¶°¤¤«×¡]SV¡^µ¥ªÑÅvÅܼƧ@¬°¦ÛÅܼơ]X¡¡^F¨Ã¤À§O«Ø¥ß°jÂk¼Ò«¬ÀËÅç¤T¶µ®Ä²v«ü¼Ð»P¦UªÑÅvÅܼƶ¡¤§¬ÛÃö©Ê¡C
38
²Ä¤@¸`
¼Ë¥»¤½¥q°ò¥»¸ê®Æ
¥»¬ã¨s¥D-n¬O¥H¥»°ê¹ØÀI¤½¥q¬°±´°Q¹ï¶H¡A¦Ó°ê¤º¤@¦@16®a¹ØÀI·~ªÌ¤§¤¤¡A«n¤s¤H¹Ø¤§ªÑÅv¤j³¡¤À¥Ñ¬ü°ê°ê»Ú¶°¹Î¡]A.I.G.¡^©Ò«ù¦³¡F¦Ó¤¤¥¡«H°U§½¤§¹ØÀI³B¥»¨-¬°¤@¤½Àç©Ê½è³æ¦ì¡F¥t²Î¤@¤H¹Ø¤Î©¯ºÖ¤H¹Ø¥Ñ©óµLªk¨ú±o¬ÛÃö°]³ø¸ê®Æ¡A¬G¥»¬ã¨s¤§¼Ë¥»©ó¦©°£¤W-z4®a«á¬°¥xÆW¡B«O¸Û¡B°ê®õ¡B¤¤°ê¡B°êµØ¡B·s¥ú¡B´I¨¹¡B°êÄ_¡B¤T°Ó¡B¿³¹A¡B»·¶¯¤Î§»®õµ¥12®a¥»°ê¹ØÀI·~ªÌ¡]ªí4.1¡C¡^
¥»¤å¤§¸ê®Æ¨Ó·½¤Î¬ã¨sÆ[¹î´Á¶¡¡A¦b¿Å¶q¹ØÀI¤½¥q¸gÀç®Ä²v¤§¦U¶µ§ë¤J²£¥X¸ê®Æ¡A¬°¥Á°ê86-88¦~«×¤§¹ØÀI¤½·|©Òµo¦æ¤§¡u¤H¹Ø«OÀI·~°È²Î-p¦~³ø¡¡vF¦Ó¦U¹ØÀI·~ªÌ¤§ªÑÅvµ²ºc¤Î°ª¶¥¥DºÞÁ~¹Sµ¥¬ÛÃö´¦ÅS¨Æ¶µ¡A¥Ñ©ó¸Óµ¥¸ê®ÆÄݤ½¥q¤º³¡Àç¹B¤§-«-n¨Æ¶µ¡A¹ØÀI¦~³ø¥ç©Î¹ØÀI¤½·|§¡µL±q¨ú±o¡F¦¹³¡¥÷¼Æ¾Ú«Y³z¹L¡u°]¹Îªk¤HÃÒ¨éº[´Á³f¥«³õµo®i°òª÷·|¡v¤§¹Ï®Ñ«Ç¨åÂáA¤è¯à¶¶§Q¨ú±o¡C
39
ªí
4.1 ¥»¬ã¨s¿ï¨ú¤§¹ØÀI¤½¥q°ò¥»¸ê®Æ
·~ªÌ¦¨¥ß®É¶¡(¥Á°ê)¸ê¥»ÃB(»õ¤¸)¥xÆW«O¸Û36.12
15
¸gÀç·~°È
-Ó¤H»P¹ÎÅ餧¹ØÀI.¶Ë®`ÀI.°·±dÀI
¤½¶}µo¦æ¤W¥«
51.05 30
-Ó¤H»P¹ÎÅ餧¹ØÀI.¶Ë®`ÀI.°·±dÀI
¤½¶}µo¦æ
°ê®õ51.08 482
-Ó¤H»P¹ÎÅ餧¹ØÀI.¶Ë®`ÀI.°·±dÀI
¤W¥«
¤¤°ê52.04 57
-Ó¤H»P¹ÎÅ餧¹ØÀI.¶Ë®`ÀI.°·±dÀI
¤W¥«
°êµØ52.07 20
-Ó¤H»P¹ÎÅ餧¹ØÀI.¶Ë®`ÀI.°·±dÀI
¤½¶}µo¦æ
·s¥ú52.07 210
-Ó¤H»P¹ÎÅ餧¹ØÀI.¶Ë®`ÀI.°·±dÀI
¤W¥«
´I¨¹82.06 48
-Ó¤H»P¹ÎÅ餧¹ØÀI.¶Ë®`ÀI.°·±dÀI
¤½¶}µo¦æ
°êÄ_82.06 27
-Ó¤H»P¹ÎÅ餧¹ØÀI.¶Ë®`ÀI.°·±dÀI
¤½¶}µo¦æ
¤T°Ó82.06 39
-Ó¤H»P¹ÎÅ餧¹ØÀI.¶Ë®`ÀI.°·±dÀI
¤½¶}µo¦æ
¿³¹A82.07 26
-Ó¤H»P¹ÎÅ餧¹ØÀI.¶Ë®`ÀI.°·±dÀI
¤½¶}µo¦æ
»·¶¯82.11 75
-Ó¤H»P¹ÎÅ餧¹ØÀI.¶Ë®`ÀI.°·±dÀI
¤½¶}µo¦æ
§»®õ83.07 46
-Ó¤H»P¹ÎÅ餧¹ØÀI.¶Ë®`ÀI.°·±dÀI
¤½¶}µo¦æ
¸ê®Æ¨Ó·½¡G¤H¹Ø«OÀI·~°È²Î-p¦~³ø¡]¥Á
88¡^
40
¤@¡B ¹ØÀI¤½¥q®Ä²v¿Å¶q«ü¼Ð¤§©w¸q»P¸ê®Æ³B²z
¥»¬ã¨s©ó²Ä¤T³¹¤¤°Ñ¦Ò°ê¤º¥~¤åÄm¡A-ݤ§¦Ò¶q°ê¤º¹ØÀI·~¤§¸gÀç¯S©Ê»P²{ªp¡AÅv¿Å¤§«á¤©¥H¿ï¨ú¤§§ë¤J²£¥X¶µ«ü¼Ð©w¸q¦p¤U
ªí4.2 ¥»¬ã¨s¤§§ë¤J²£¥X©w¸q
«ü¼Ð
©w¸q
«ü¤º³¡ªA°ÈªºÁ`°È³¡¤H¨Æ
I1:¤º¶Ô¤H-û
³¡«´¬ù³¡¥ø¹º³¡°]°È³¡«O¥þ³¡¡Kµ¥³¡ªù¤§¤H-û,¥H¦~©³²Î-p¤H¼Æ¬°·Ç «ü¥~¶Ô³æ¦ì¦X®æµn³°¤§±MI2:¥~¶Ô¤H-û
¾»P«D±M¾·~°È¤H-û,¥H¤H¼Æ¦~©³¤§²Î-p¤H¼Æ¬°·Ç
I3:·~°ÈºÞ²z¶O¥Î 01:«OÀIµ¹¥I
²Î-p¦~³ø¤¤·l¯q-pºâªí©Ò°O¸ü¤§ª÷ÃB ·í¦~«×¤§²z½ßª÷ÃB
¦Ê¸U¤¸ ¦Ê¸U¤¸ ¤H¼Æ ³æ¦ì
·í¦~¤§·Ç³Æª÷ÃB«×»P«e¤@02:·Ç³Æª÷¼W¥[ÃB ¦Ê¸U¤¸
¦~«×¤§®tÃB¬°¼W¥[¤§³¡¥÷
¨Ì¾Ú«e¸`©Ò¿ï¨ú¤§¼Ë¥»¤½¥q¡]DMU¡^¥H¤Î§ë¤J²£¥X¤§¶µ¥Ø¡A·J¾ã¥Á°ê86-88¤T-Ó¦~«×¤§¦U¶µ«ü¼Ð¼Æ¾Ú¾ã²z¦p¤U¡G
41
ªí
4.3 ¥Á°ê86-88¦~DMU¸ê®Æ¾ã²z
DMU ¥~¶Ô¤H¼Æ ¤º¶Ô¤H¼Æ ·~°ÈºÞ²z¶O «OÀIµ¹¥I 88¦~«× ¥xÆW «O¸Û °ê®õ ¤¤°ê °êµØ ·s¥ú ´I¨¹ °êÄ_ ¤T°Ó ¿³¹A »·¶¯ §»®õ 87¦~«× ¥xÆW «O¸Û °ê®õ ¤¤°ê °êµØ ·s¥ú ´I¨¹ °êÄ_
·Ç³Æª÷¼W¥[
ÃB
IN1 4588 5083 53225 2676 8126 30940 10670 466 10548 2765 4028 3847 5328 5936 50989 2466 7731 31212 10156 622
IN2 768 518 6724 709 1531 4181 572 220 755 302 497 390 787 485 6997 732 1502 4335 535 194
IN3(¦Ê¸U) O1(¦Ê¸U) O2(¦Ê¸U) 803.87 899.09 21916.77 1906.44 2421.75 9908.40 880.94 462.60 1324.84 439.32 830.64 749.43 756.16 805.57 26647.71 1134.47 2562.26 17202.90 803.32 274.67
42
7694.84 1966.62 85676.90 4971.71 9365.57 43853.90 2016.66 672.71 3069.74 433.91 1857.61 1757.10
7938.42 1191.86 82131.80 4129.08 8532.89 37609.30 878.91 377.57
8548.22 5028.58 91711.59 10286.53 12646.07 44368.11 13464.79 1118.29 7893.99 903.95 3494.27 2650.66
5467.33 4010.90 88319.24 9038.19 7313.03 39825.84 4981.33 508.08
¤T°Ó
8776 2435 4962 8180 7369 4794 64755 2126 8494 45292 8912 3944 7625 3181 3764 6031
7097 241 519 481 417 515 7161 740 1395 4984 464 193 624 237 409 407
1086.79 401.58 1976.63 844.41 739.10 768.78 32287.09 1259.78 2231.89 21166.10 730.98 326.18 930.46 406.07 1236.69 776.83
2106.49 267.02 1234.45 1228.68
7118.39 885.40 69837.13 3626.06 7426.89 34340.37 558.00 167.05 929.15 218.48 231.45 344.90
4833.51 756.12 3610.63 2260.98
5030.08 1904.83 81480.68 6887.98 7911.10 39928.23 2708.73 228.78 3657.25 609.61 2343.48 2069.88
¿³¹A »·¶¯ §»®õ 86¦~«× ¥xÆW «O¸Û °ê®õ ¤¤°ê °êµØ ·s¥ú ´I¨¹ °êÄ_ ¤T°Ó ¿³¹A »·¶¯ §»®õ
¸ê®Æ¨Ó·½¡G¤¤µØ¥Á°ê¹ØÀI¤½·|²Î-p¦~³ø
¤G¡B ¼Ë¥»¤½¥qªÑÅvµ²ºc»P°ª¶¥¥DºÞÁ~¹S¸ê®Æ¾ã²z
¥»¬ã¨s¤§²Ä¤G¶¥¬q¬°¿Å¶q¸gÀç®Ä²v»PªÑÅvÅܼƥH¤Î°ª¶¥¥DºÞÁ~¹S¤§¶¡ªº¼vÅTµ{«×¡A¦Ó¥H¸³ºÊ¨Æ«ùªÑ¤ñ²v¡]CHS¡¡BÁ`¸g²zÁ~¹^S¡]¥H¤ÎªÑÅv¶°¤¤«×¡]SV¡^µ¥¤T¶µ¥N²zÅܼƬ°¬ã¨sÅܼơC
¨ä¤¤¡A¸³ºÊ¨Æ«ùªÑ¤ñ²v¡]CHS¡^¥H¤ÎÁ`¸g²zÁ~¹S¡]COM¡^¤§¬ÛÃö¼Æ¾Ú¡A¥H¦U¹ØÀI·~ªÌ¥Z¸ü©ó°]°È³ø§i®Ñ¥H¤Î-PªÑªF¦~³ø¤W¡A©Ò´¦ÅS
43
COM¡^
¤§-ì©l¸ê®Æ¬°°Ñ¦Ò¨Ì¾Ú¡C
¦ÓªÑÅv¶°¤¤«×¡]SV¡^¤§¼Æ¾Ú¡A¬°¥»¬ã¨s¨Ì¾Ú¤§¬ã¨s½×¤å¤¤¡A©Ò±Ä¥Î¤§¤èªk-pºâ¦Ó±o¡AÁ|¨Ò»¡©ú¦p¤U¡G
«ùªÑ¤À¯Å 1-999
1,000-5,000 5,001-10,000 10,001-20,000 15,001-20,000
. . .
800,001-1,000,000 1,000,001¥H¤W
¦X-p
ªÑªF¤H¼Æ4,000
7,040 1,646 647 286 . . . 5 21 14,279
«ù¦³ªÑ¼Æ 1,786,221 16,547,057 11,725,519 8,133,113 5,001,113
. . . 4,426,762 196,649,410 281,822,350
«ùªÑ¤ñ²v(%)
0.63 5.87 4.16 2.89 1.78 . . . 1.57 69.78 100
SV=0.632+5.872+4.162+2.892+1.782+¡E¡E¡E+1.572+69.782
44
ªí4.4 ¬ã¨s¼Ë¥»¥Á°ê86-88¦~¤§¥-§¡¼Æ¾Ú
DMU
CHS 75.79% 35.85% 24.17% 36.60% 67.70% 35% 54.21% 80% 51% 54.50% 42.80% 43.38%
COM 2400.00 5109.00 7441 11749.00 4800.00 12710.00 5979.00 2968.00 4323.00 3492.00 4914.00 2545
SV 0.41 0.63 0.39 0.36 0.71 0.95 0.57 0.81 0.71 0.41 0.71 0.26
A B C D E F G H I J K L
¸ê®Æ¨Ó·½¡G¦U¹ØÀI¤½¥q°]°È¦~³ø
45
²Ä¤G¸`
¸gÀç®Ä²v¤ÀªRµ²ªG
¥»¬ã¨s¥H¸ê®Æ¥]µ¸¤ÀªRªk¡]DEA¡^¶i¦æ12®a¼Ë¥»¤½¥q¤§¬Û¹ï¸gÀç®Ä²v¤§µû¦ô¡A¨ä-pºâµ²ªG¾ã²z¦p¤U¡C
ªí4.5 DMU¤§¸gÀç®Ä²v-È
DMU A B C D E F G H I J K L
©T©w³W¼Ò³ø¹SÅܰʳW¼Ò³ø¹S
³W¼Ò³ø³W¼Ò®Ä²v
¹Sª¬ºA¡]§Þ³N®Ä²v¡^ ¡]¯Âºé§Þ³N®Ä²v¡^1.00 0.59 1.00 1.00 0.72 0.92 1.00 0.92 0.58 0.20 0.47 0.47
1.00 0.64 1.00 1.00 0.84 1.00 1.00 1.00 0.58 1.00 0.54 0.67
1.00 0.93 1.00 1.00 0.85 0.92 1.00 0.92 0.99 0.20 0.89 0.70
CRS IRS CRS CRS IRS DRS IRS IRS IRS IRS IRS IRS
¡¯ ¥»¬ã¨s-pºâ¦Ó±o¡A¨ä¤¤¡GCRS¬°©T©w³W¼Ò³ø¹S¡FIRSªí³W¼Ò³ø¹S»¼¼W¡ADRSªí¥Ü³W¼Ò³ø¹S»¼´î
¥Ñ©ó¥»¬ã¨s¥HBanker¡BCharnes¡BCooper¡]1984¡^¤§¼Ò¦¡¶i¦æ®Ä
46
²v¤ÀªR¡A¸û¤§
CCR¼Ò¦¡¥u¯à©ó¡u©T©w³W¼Ò³ø¹S¡v¤§°²³]¤U¨Dºâ®Ä²v
¦Ó¨¥¡ABCC¼Ò¦¡¥i¥H©ñ¼e¨ä°²³]¬°¡uÅܰʳW¼Ò³ø¹S¡v¥H¨Dºâ¥X¦UDMUªº¡u¯Âºé§Þ³N®Ä²v¡v¡F¦]¦¹¡u§Þ³N®Ä²v¡vªº¿Å¶q¬O¥H©T©w³W¼Ò³ø¹S¤U¥Í²£Ãä¬É¬°°ò·Ç¡A¦Ó¡u¯Âºé§Þ³N®Ä²v¡v«h¥H¥iÅܳW¼Ò³ø¹S¤U¥Í²£Ãä¬É¬°°ò·Ç¡C¨ä¤TªÌÃö«Y¦¡¬°¡G¡u§Þ³N®Ä²v-È¡v¡]TE¡^¡×¡u¯Âºé§Þ³N®Ä²v-È¡]¡vPTE¡^¡Ñ¡u³W¼Ò®Ä²v-È¡]¡vSE¡C¡^
¥Ñ¤W-z¡]ªí4.5¡^©Ò¦C¥X¤§¦U¶µ¤ÀªR¼Æ¾Ú¨Ó¬Ý¡A¦b¡u©T©w³W¼Ò³ø¹S¡v¤§°²³]¤U¡A¶È¥|®a·~ªÌ¹F¨ì¨ä¡u®Ä²v«e½t]¡v
A.C.D.G¡¡^F-Y¬O§ï
Åܬ°¡uÅܰʳW¼Ò³ø¹S¡v¤§°²³]¡A¤@¯ë¦Ó¨¥¦UDMU¤§®Ä²v«ü¼Ð¬Ò·|¦³©Ò§ï¶i¡A¦p¤Wªí¤§¡]A.C.D.F.G.H.J¡^¨ä®Ä²v-ȬҬ°1¡C
¥»¤å±N¤À§O¥H¡u§Þ³N®Ä²v¡B¡v¡u¯Âºé§Þ³N®Ä²v¡v¥H¤Î¡u³W¼Ò®Ä²v¡v¤§®Ä²v«ü¼Ð¨ÓÀËÅ祻¬ã¨s¤§¦U¶µ°²»¡¡A°jÂk¤ÀªR¤§µ²ªG±N°O¸ü©ó«á¡C
47
²Ä¤T¸`
¦^Âk¼Ò«¬¹êµýµ²ªG
¥»¸`±N¥H¹ØÀI¤½¥q¤§¤T¶µ¸gÀç®Ä²v—©T©w³W¼Ò³ø¹S¤U¤§§Þ³N®Ä²v¡]CRS¡^¡B¥iÅܳW¼Ò³ø¹S¤U¤§§Þ³N®Ä²v¡]VRS¡^¥H¤Î³W¼Ò®Ä²v¡]SCALE¡¡^AÀËÅç³o¤T¶µ®Ä²v«ü¼Ð»P¡uªÑÅvµ²ºc¡B¡v¡uÁ`¸g²zÁ~¹S¡vÅܼƤ§¶¡ªºÃö«Y¡C¦U¶µ²Î-p¼Æ¦r¾ã²z¦p¤Uªí
ªí4.6 ¹êÃÒ¤ÀªR²Î-p
ºI¶Z CHS COM SV R
«Y¼Æ -0.008 0.991 0.007 -0.263
CRS
t ²Î-p -0.01 1.68 2.33*
VRS «Y¼Æ 0.316 1.01 0.005 -0.5
t ²Î-p 1.35 2.9*3.0*
SCALE «Y¼Æ 0.58 0.107 0.002 0.19
t ²Î-p 1.46 0.18 0.69 0.48
-0.66 -2.13 76.00%
64.20% 37.40%
* ªí¥ÜÅãµÛ¡]£\\=0.05¡^
¥Ñªí4-6¤§¹êÃÒ¤ÀªR¥iª¾¡A©ó¡u©T©w³W¼Ò³ø¹S¡v¤§°²³]¤U¡AÁ`¸g²zÁ~¹Sµ¹¥I¤§¤ô·Ç·U°ª¡A«h¹ØÀI¤½¥q¤§¸gÀç®Ä²v·U¨Î¡A¦b0.05ªºÀË©w¤ô·Ç¤§¤U¡A¼Æ¾Ú§e²{ÅãµÛ¤§¼vÅT¡A¤ä«ù¥»¤å¤§¬ã¨s°²³]¤G---¡uÁ`¸g²z¤§Á~¹S¤ô·Ç·U°ª¡A¤½¥q¤§¸gÀç®Ä²v·U¨Î¡v
¦b¡uÅܰʳW¼Ò³ø¹S¡v¤§°²³]ªº±¡ªp¤U¡A¥»¤å¤§¨â¶µªÑÅvÅܼơu¸³ºÊ¨Æ«ùªÑ¤ñ²v¡v¥H¤Î¡uÁ`¸g²zÁ~¹S¤ô·Ç¡v¬Ò¦³ÅãµÛ©Ê¤§ÀËÅç®ÄªG¡A§Y
48
²Å¦X¤F¥»¬ã¨s¤§°²³]¤@¤Î°²³]¤G¡C
¦bÀËÅç¹ØÀI¤½¥q¤§¡u³W¼Ò®Ä²v¡v®É¡A¥»¬ã¨s©Ò±Ä¥Î¤§¤T¶µªÑÅvÅܼơA¸g¹L¹êÃÒ¤ÀªR¬Ò¥¼¯à³q¹LÅãµÛ©ÊÀËÅç¡C
¹ï©ó¹ØÀI¤½¥q¤§¡uªÑÅv¶°¤¤«×¡v¹ï©ó¸gÀç®Ä²vªº¹êÃÒµ²ªG¦Ó¨¥¡A¤£½×¬°¦óºØ®Ä²v«ü¼Ð¡]§Þ³N®Ä²v¡B¯Âºé§Þ³N®Ä²v¡B³W¼Ò®Ä²v¡^¬Ò¥¼§e²{ÅãµÛ©Ê¤§¤ÏÀ³¡A³o¤]·N¨ýµÛ¹ØÀI¤½¥qªºªÑÅv¤À´²µ{«×»P§_¡A¹ï©ó¤½¥qªº¸gÀç®Ä²v¨ÃµLªk²£¥ÍÅãµÛ©Êªº¼vÅT¡F¦ý-ȱo¥t¤Hª`·Nªº¬O¡A¥Ñ¡uªÑÅv¤¤«×¡v¤§¹êÃÒ«Y¼Æ¨Ó¬Ý¡A¤£½×¬O³B©ó¡u©T©w³W¼Ò³ø¹S¡v©Î¡uÅܰʳW¼Ò³ø¹S¡v¤§°²³]ª¬ªp¤U¬Ò¬°-t-È¡A¬O§_¯à¾Ú¦¹±À½×¹ØÀI¤½¥qªº¡uªÑÅv¶°¤¤µ{«×·U°ª¡¡vA¤Ï¦Ó¾É-P¤F¤£¨Îªº¸gÀç®Ä²v¡A¶i¦Ó±À½×¦¹²{¶H¦LÃÒ¤F¡u¾d©T©Ê°²»¡¡v¡H¹ï©ó¦¹¶µ¹êÃÒ¤ÀªR¡A©|¦³«Ý²Ö¿n«áÄò§ó¦hªº¬ã¨sµ²ªG¤è¯à¦³©Ò©w½×¡C
49
²Ä¥î³¹ µ²½×»P«Øij
²Ä¤@¸` µ²½×
¥xÆWªº¹ØÀI¥«³õ¦Û¥þ-±¶}©ñ¡]¥Á83¡^¦Ü¤µ¡AµL½×¬O¦b¹ØÀI¤½¥qªº®a¼Æ¤W¡A¥~¶Ô¤H-ûªºÁ`¤H¼Æ¡A¥H¤Î¥þÅé°ê¥Áªº§ë«O¤ñ²v»P§ë«Oª÷ÃB¡A¬Ò§e²{¥X¤F³v¦~¨³³tÃk¤É¤§¶Õ¡F³o¤@¤è-±Åã¥Ü¤F¾ãÅé¹ØÀI²£·~ªº½´«kµo®i¡A¥t¤@¤è-±¥çÅã¥Ü¥X¤F¦U®a·~ªÌ¤§¶¡¹ê¤w-±Á{¤F°ª«×¥Õ¼ö¤ÆªºÄvª§§½-±¡C
¥Ñ©ó¹ØÀI°Ó«~¨ã¦³±j¯Pªº¤½¯q©Ê½è¡A¹ØÀI·~ªÌ¤§¸gÀ禨±Ñ§ó¬O¼vÅT¾ãÅéªÀ·|ª÷¿Ä¯´§Ç¬Æ¯P¡A¦]¦¹µL½×¬O¦b¤½¥q³]¥ß®Éªº¸ê¥»ÃB«×¦³©Ò--¨î¥~¡AÁ|¤Z-«-n¸g²z¤Hªº±M·~¾ÇÃÑ¡B¥~¶Ô¤H-ûªºÃÒ·Ó¸ê®æ¥H¤Î¦U¶µ°Ó«~ªº»ù®æ¨î©w¤W¡A¬Ò¨ü¨ìºÊ²z³æ¦ìªºÄY®æ¼f¬d¤Î-n¨D¡F¦Ó©ó¦¹±¡ªp¤§¤U¦U·~ªÌ¤§¶¡¹ê¨ã¦³°ª«×ªº¬ÛÃö©Ê¡FÁ|¨Ò¦Ó¨¥¬Y¤@-Ó§O·~ªÌ¨ÃµLªk¯àÂǥѡu§C»ùµ¦²¤¡v¨Ó¹F¨ì¨³³tÂX®i·~°È¤§¥Øªº¡A¦]¬°¨ä-pºâ«O¶O©Ò¨Ï¥Î¤§¹w©w§Q²v¡B¶O¥Î²v¤Î¦º¤`²v¬Ò¦³¨ä¦X²z¤§³W½d¡C
¦]¦¹¹ØÀI·~ªÌ¤§¶¡ªº¸gÀç®Ä²v±EÀu±E¦H¡A»P¦U·~ªÌ¸gÀçºÞ²z§Þ³N¤§¨}æÕ®§®§¬ÛÃö¡F¦Ó¥»¤å¥H¸gÀÙ¤ÀªR©Ò°Q½×¡u®Ä²v¡v¤§¨¤«×¡A±q¡u¥Í²£Ãä¬É¡]¡vproduction frontier¡^ªº·§©À¥Xµo¡AÂÇ¡u¸ê®Æ¥]µ¸¤ÀªR¡vªk¨Ó¤ÀªR¦U¹ØÀI·~ªÌ¤§¦U¶µ®Ä²v«ü¼Ð¡C
¦Ó¥»¤å±q¹ØÀI·~ªÌ¤§ªÑÅvµ²ºc¯S©Ê¡A¨Ó±´°Q¦¹¤@Åܼƹï©ó¦U¶µ¸gÀç®Ä²vªº¼vÅTµ{«×¡A¸g¥Ñ¹êÃÒ¤ÀªR¤§¹Lµ{¡A±N¨äµ²ªG¾ã²z¦p¤U¡G
¤@¡B
¸g¥Ñ¹êÃÒ¤ÀªR¤§µ²ªG¥iª¾¡AµL½×¬O¦b¡u©T©w³W¼Ò³ø¹S¡v¤§°²³]¤U¡A¥ç©Î¡uÅܰʳW¼Ò³ø¹S¡v¡A¹ØÀI¤½¥q¤§¡uÁ`¸g²zÁ~¹S¡v·U°ª¡A¨ä¸gÀç®Ä²v·U¨Î¡F¦¹¶µµ²½×²Å¦X¬ã¨s°²³]¤G¡C
¤G¡B
-Y©ó¡uÅܰʳW¼Ò³ø¹S¡v¤§°²³]¤U¡A¹ØÀI¤½¥qªº¡u¸³ºÊ¨Æ
50
«ùªÑ¤ñ²v¡v·U°ª¡A«h¤½¥qªº¸gÀç®Ä²v·U¨Î¡A²Å¦X¥»¤å¤§¬ã¨s°²³]¤@¡F¦Ó¦¹¶µµ²½×»P³¯¾åªå¡]¥Á
89¡^¤@¤å©Ò±o¤§
µ²½×¬Û²Å¡C
¤T¡B
ÁöµM¥»¬ã¨s¤§¦U¶µ¸gÀç®Ä²v¡A»P¹ØÀI¤½¥q¤§¡uªÑÅv¤À´²µ{«×¡v¨Ã¥¼¦³ÅãµÛ¤§ÃöÁp¡A¦ý©Ò±o¨ìªº¨â¶µ«Y¼Æ¬Ò¬°¡u-t-È¡v¡A¦ü¥GÅã¥ÜªÑÅvªº·U§Î¶°¤¤¤Ï¤£§Q©ó¸gÀç®Ä²v¡A´N¦¹ªì¨B¤§µ²½×»P³¯¾åªå¡]¥Á89¡^¤@¤å©Ò±o¤§µ²½×¨Ã¤£¬Û¦P¡A¦ý¥»¤å´N¦¹½×ÂI«ù«O¯d¤§ºA«×¡C
51
²Ä¤G¸`
«áÄò¬ã¨s«Øij
¥Ñ©ó°ê¤º¤§¹ØÀI¤½¥q¤W¥«¤WÂd·~ªÌ¶È¥u¥|®a¡A¦]¦¹¹ï©ó¬ÛÃöªÑÅvµ²ºc¤§ÅܼƸê®Æ´¦ÅS¦³--¡F¦Ó°ê¤º¤½¥q¤§¡uªÑªF·|¦~³ø¡v¥ç©Î¡u°]°È³ø§i®Ñ¡vµL½×¬O©óºÊ²z³æ¦ì¥ç©Î¹ØÀI¤½·|¬ÒµL±q¨ú±o¡A¥~°Ó¤À¤½¥q¤§¬ÛÃö¸ê®Æ¥ç¤£¤½¶}¡A¹E¨Ï±o¥»¬ã¨s¤§--¨î»á¦h¡C
¦ý¥»¬ã¨s¥H¬°¡A¹ØÀI·~ªÌ¤§¦U¶µÀç¹B¸ê®ÆÀ³§@¾A«×¤§¤½¶}¡A¦¹¬°¼vÅT²³¦h¤§§ë«O¤j²³Åv¯q¡AÂǪ̦U·~ªÌ¤§¬ÛÃö¸ê°T´¦ÅS¡A¯à¦³§U©ó¤F¸Ñ¦U¤½¥q¤§¸gÀ禨ªG¬°¦ó¡A-Ú¯à¥[¥HºÊ·þ¡C
¥»¬ã¨s¥ý¥H¡u¸ê®Æ¥]µ¸¤ÀªR¡v¤§²Î-p¤èªkµû¦ô¦U·~ªÌ¤§¦U¶µ¸gÀç®Ä²v¡A¦Ó«á¥HªÑÅvµ²ºcÅܼƹï©ó¦U¶µ®Ä²v«ü¼Ð¨Ó§@ÀËÅç¡A¦¹¬°¹L¥h¾ÇªÌ©Ò¥¼¦³¹L¹Á¸ÕªÌ¡A¦]¦¹µ§ªÌ´£¥X¤TÂI¨Ñ«áÄò¬ã¨s¾ÇªÌ°Ñ¦Ò¡G
¤@¡B¥HDEAªk¿Å¶q¹ØÀI¤½¥q¸gÀç®Ä²v¤è-±¡A¥»¤å²v¥ý¥H¡u²z½ß¤ä¥X¡v¤Î¡u·Ç³Æª÷¼W¥[ÃB«×¡v¬°¨ä¡u²£¥X¡v¤§¥N²zÅܼơA»P¹L¥h¾ÇªÌ©Ò¨Ï¥Î¤§¡u«O¶O¦¬¤J¡v¦³©Ò®t²§¡F«áÄò¬ã¨sªÌ©Î¥i¥[¥H¤ñ¸û¦U¡u²£¥X¡vÅܼƿï¨ú¤§¤£¦P¡A¦Ó¬O§_¦³¤£¦P¤§µ²ªG¡C
¤G¡B¥»¤å¶È¥H°ê¤º¹ØÀI¤½¥q¬°¬ã¨s¼Ë¥»¡A«áÄòªÌ¦ü¥i´N²£ÀI·~ªÌ¤§¬ÛÃöijÃD¥[¥H¬ã¨s¡C
¤T¡B-YºÊ²z³æ¦ì©ú¥O¥~°Ó¤½¥q»Ý´¦ÅS¬ÛÃö¤§ªÑÅv¸ê®Æ«á¡A·í¥i¨Ö¤J¬ã¨s½d³ò¤§¤º¡A©Î¥iÀËÅ祻°ê—¥~°Ó·~ªÌ¶¡¤§®t²§©Ê¡C
52
°Ñ¦Ò¤åÄm
¤¤¤å³¡¤À
§õ§ÓµØ¡A»OÆW¥ø·~ÁZ®Äµû¦ô¤è¦¡¤§¬ã¨s¡A°ê¥ß¬Fªv¤j¾Ç¥ø¬ã©ÒºÓ¤h½×
¤å¡A¥Á°ê69¦~6¤ë¡C
§õ§g«Ì¡A¹ØÀI¤½¥q¸gÀç®Ä²v¤§¿Å¶q¸ê®Æ¥]µ¸¤ÀªRªk¤§À³¥Î¡A¨p¥ß³{¥Ò
¤j¾Ç«O¬ã©ÒºÓ¤h½×¤å¡A¥Á°ê83¦~6¤ë¡C
ªô¼z§u¡A§Ú°ê¤W¥«¤½¥q¸³¨Æ·|¯S©Ê»P¸³¨Æ«D±`³W¥«³õ¦æ¬°¤§¬ã¨s¡A°ê
¥ß¥xÆW¤j¾Ç·|¬ã©ÒºÓ¤h½×¤å¡A¥Á°ê83¦~6¤ë¡C
§d°êµØ¡A¥xÆW¦a°Ï¹ØÀI·~¥ø·~§Î¶H»P¸gÀçÁZ®Ä¤§Ãö«Y¡A¨p¥ß»Ê¶Ç¤j¾Ç
ºÞ¬ì©ÒºÓ¤h½×¤å¡A¥Á°ê86¦~6¤ë¡C
§d®aÁn¡A¡u³Ò¸êÃö«Yªºµo®i»P¥ø·~¸gÀ給²¤¡v¡A²z½×»P¬Fµ¦¡A²Ä3¨÷²Ä
3´Á¡A¥Á°ê78¦~4¤ë¡C
ªL¬³Î]¡A°]°ÈºÞ²z—²z½×»P¹ê°È¡AµØ®õ®Ñ§½¡A¥Á°ê79¦~2¤ë¡C ªL±Ò®p¡A¤u§@ÁZ®Ä¹w´ú¼Ò¦¡¤§¬ã¨s¡A¨p¥ßªF®ü¤j¾ÇºÞ¬ã©ÒºÓ¤h½×¤å¡A
¥Á°ê76¦~6¤ë¡C
ªL¨|¶®¡A§Ú°ê¤W¥«¤½¥q¸³¨Æ·|¯S©Ê»P¬Õ¾l¾ÞÁa²{¶H¤§¬ã¨s¡A°ê¥ß¥xÆW
¤j¾Ç·|¬ã©ÒºÓ¤h½×¤å¡A¥Á°ê82¦~6¤ë¡C
53
¬x¤d´f¡A¥ø·~±Ð¨|°V½m¨î«×»P¸gÀçÁZ®Ä¤§¬ÛÃö¬ã¨s¤Îµû¦ô¡A¨p¥ß²H¦¿
¤j¾ÇºÞ¬ì©ÒºÓ¤h½×¤å¡A¥Á°ê
81¦~6¤ë¡C
³¯¶©ÄQ¡A²{¥N°]°ÈºÞ²z—²z½×»PÀ³¥Î¡AµØ®õ®Ñ§½¡A¥Á°ê81¦~2¤ë¡C ³¯ßNªå¡A±q¥N²z²z½×¤§Æ[ÂI±´°QªÑÅvµ²ºc¹ï«OÀI¸gÀ礧¼vÅT¡A°ê¥ß¬F
ªv¤j¾Ç-·ºÞ©ÒºÓ¤h½×¤å¡A¥Á°ê89¦~6¤ë¡C
³¯³Õµa¡A¥ø·~¹q¸£¤Æ¤§²Õ´»P¨t²Î¦]¯À¹ï¥ø·~ÁZ®Ä¼vÅT¤§¬ã¨s¡A°ê¥ß
¥xÆW¬ì§Þ¤j¾Ç¤u§Þ©ÒºÓ¤h½×¤å¡A¥Á°ê77¦~6¤ë¡C
¶Àà±¥ú¡A§Ú°ê¤W¥«¤½¥q¸³¨Æ·|¯S©Ê»P¸gÀçÁZ®Ä¤§¬ã¨s¡A°ê¥ß¥xÆW¤j¾Ç
·|¬ã©ÒºÓ¤h½×¤å¡A¥Á°ê81¦~6¤ë¡C
±i»·»«¡A¥xÆW¦a°Ï¤H¹Ø«OÀI·~¦¨¥»µ²ºc¹êÃÒ¤ÀªR¡A°ê¥ß¤¤¥¡¤j¾Ç²£¸g
©ÒºÓ¤h½×¤å¡A¥Á°ê77¦~6¤ë¡C
¸-¿Aµ×¡A¹ØÀI·~¸gÀçÁZ®Ä¿Å¶q«ü¼Ð¤§¬ã¨s¡A¨p¥ß³{¥Ò¤j¾Ç«O¬ã©ÒºÓ¤h
½×¤å¡A¥Á°ê89¦~6¤ë¡C
¾G¨q®S¡A¥xÆW¦a°Ï¹ØÀI·~¸gÀçÁZ®Ä¤§¬ã¨s¡A¨p¥ß»Ê¶Ç¤j¾ÇºÞ¬ì©ÒºÓ¤h
½×¤å¡A¥Á°ê85¦~6¤ë¡C
¾G¬°«Ö¡A°ª¶¥¥DºÞÁ~¹S-pµe»PÁ~¹S¨M©w¦]¯À¤§¬ã¨s¡A°ê¥ß¬Fªv¤j¾Ç¥ø
¬ã©ÒºÓ¤h½×¤å¡A¥Á°ê81¦~6¤ë
¿½¥°¼Ý¡A°ª¶¥ºÞ²zÁ~¹S-pµe»P¥ø·~Àç¹BÁZ®ÄÃö«Y¤§¬ã¨s¡A ¨p¥ßªF§d
¤j¾ÇºÞ¬ã©ÒºÓ¤h½×¤å¡A¥Á°ê83¦~6¤ë¡C
54
¼B¯Â¤§¡A¡u¸gÀÙ³W¼Ò»P¹ØÀI¤½¥q¸gÀç®Ä²v¡A¡v«OÀI±M¥Z¡A²Ä
37¿è¡A¥Á
°ê84¦~3¤ë¡C
-^¤å³¡¤À
Aigner, D. J. and S. F. Chu (1968), \"On Estimating the Industry Production Function\Agarwal, N.,(1981),\"Determinants of Executive Compensation\Indusstrial Relations, 36-46. Barnea, A. R., R. A. Haugen and L. M. Senbet,(1981), \"A Equilibrium Analysis of Debt Financing under Costly Tax Arbitrage and Agency Problems\Becker, G. (1964), Human Capital, National Bureau of Economic Research, N.Y.
Benston, G. J., G. Hanweck, and D. B. Humphrey,(1982), \"Scale Economies in Banking: A Restructuring and Reassessment \Money, Credit and Banking, 14,435-456. Berle. Adolph A. and G. C. Means, (1932), The Modern Corporate and Private Property, New York: Macmillan. Blair, R. D., J. R. Jackson, and R.J. Vogal,(1975), \"Economies of Scale in Administration of Health Insurance\Statistics,57 ,185-189. Cicel, D. and Y. M. Carroll (1980), \"The Determinants of Executive Salaries: An Econometric Survey\Review of Economics and Statistics, 7-13.
55
Charnes, A. and W.W. Cooper (1962),\"Chance-Constraints and Normal Deviates\Journal of the American Statistical Association, 57, 134-148.
Charnes, A., W. W. Cooper and E. Rhodes (1978), \"Measuring the
Efficiency of Decision-Making Units\European Journal of Operational Research, 2, 429-444. Coughlan, A. and R. Schmidt,(1985), \"Executive Compensation,
Management Turnover, and Firm Performance: An Empirical Investigation\Cummins,D., S. Tennyson and M. Weiss,(1998), \"Efficiency, Scale
Economies, and Consolidation in the U.S. Life Insurance Industry\forthcoming in Journal of Banking and Finance. Cummins, D. and H. Zi,(1998), \"Measuring Economics Efficiency of the
U.S. Life Insurance Industry: Econometric and Mathematical Programming Techniques\Journal of Productivity Analysis. Cummins, D. and M. Weiss,(1998), \"Analyzing Firm Performance in the
Insurance Industry Using Frontier Efficiency Methods \paper from Wharton Financial Institutions Center, The Wharton School.
Demsetz, H. and K. Lehn (1985), \"The structure of Corporate Ownership:
Causes and Consequences\Journal of Political Economy, 93, 1155-1177.
Eisenhardt, K. M. (1989), \"Agency Theory: An Assessment and Review \Fama, E.,(1980), \"Agency Problem and the Theory of the Firm\Journal of Political Economy, 88(2), 288-307. Farrell, M.J.,(1957), \"The Measurement of Productivity Efficiency\
Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series A, General, 120, 253-281.
Fecher, F. , Kessler, D., Perelman, S. and Pestieay, P.(1993), \"Productive
Performance of the French Insurance Indursty\Journal of Productivity Analysis,4,77-93 Frinkelstein, S. and D. C. Hambrick,(1988), \"Chief Executive
Compensation: A Synthesis and Reconciliation\Strategic Management Journal, 9, 543-558.
56
¡Ä¡Ä¡Ä¡Ä¡Ä¡Ä¡Ä¡Ä
and¡Ä¡Ä¡Ä¡Ä¡Ä¡Ä¡Ä¡Ä ,(1989), \"Chief Executive
Compensation: A Study of the Intersection of Markets and
Political Process\Geehan, R.,(1977), \"Return to Scale in the Life Insurance\Bell Journal of Economics,8,497-514. Grace, M. and S. Timme,(1992), \"An Examination of Cost Economies in Life Insurance Industry, Journal of Risk and Insurance,59,72-103. Hettenhouse, G. W. (1971), \"Compensation Cafeteria for Top Executive\Hill, C. W. and P. Phan (1991), \"CEO Tenure as a Determinant of CEO Pay\Houston, D. B., and R. M. Simon,(1970), \"Economies of Scale in Financial Institutions: A Study in Life Insurance\38:6,856-864.
Jensen, M. C. and W. H. Meckling,(1976), \"Theory of the Firm: Managerial Behavior-Agency Cost and Ownership Structure\ Journal of Financial and Economics ,3, 305-360. Kesner, I. F.,(1987), \"Directions Stock Ownership and Organization Performance : An Investigation of Fortune 500 companies\Journal of Management,13,499-507. Lewellen, W.G. (1971), The Ownership Income of Management, NBER, New York.
Miller, M. H. and M. S. Scholes,(1981), Executive Compensation, Taxes and Incentives, Financial Economics: Essays in Honor of Paul Cootner, N.J., Prentice-Hall, 179-201. Morck R. A. Shileifer, and R. W. Vishny, (1988), \"Management Ownership and Market Valuation: An Empirical Analysis\
57
Financial Economics, 20, 293-315.
Murphy K. J.,(1985), \"Corporate Performance and Managerial Remuneration-An Empirical Analysis\Economics, 7, 11-42. Praetz, P., (1980), \"Return to Scale in U.S. Life Insurance Industry\Journal of Risk and Insurance, 47, 525-533. Pritchett, S. T., (1971), \"An Intercompany Expense Comparison for
Thirsty Life Insurers\" , Journal of Risk and Insurance, 38:2,553-562. Ross, S. A., (1973), \"The Economic Theory of Agency: The Principals
Problems\" , American Economic Review,8,134-139. Simon, H. A., (1957), \"The Compensation of Executives\
32-35.
Stulz, R. M.,(1988), \"Managerial Control of Voting Rights: Financial
Policy and the Market for Corporate Control\of Financial Economics,20,25-54. ¡A
Titman, S.,(1984), \"The Effect of Capital Structure on a Firms
Liquidation Decision\Ungson, G. and R. M. Steers,(1984), \"Motivation and Politics in Executive Compensation\Academy of Management Review, 9, 313-323.
Williamson, O. E., (1983), \"Organization Form, Residual Claimants, and
Corporate Control\Yuengert, A.,(1993), \"The Measurement of Efficiency in Life Insurance:
Estimates of a Mixed Normal-Gamma Error Model\Banking and Finance ,17,83-96.
58
因篇幅问题不能全部显示,请点此查看更多更全内容